Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• ML

  Mike Larsen

  Mar 24, 2026
  4.0
  Like the pizza from this location, but sometimes the pepperoni pizza is too oily. Last time, there was puddles of oil on top. I mean I get that pepperoni is oily after all, but I had to use napkins to soak up the oil so the crust didn't get soggy before I got it home.
• TS

  Trevor Seguin

  Mar 21, 2026
  1.0
  Super disappointed in this location. The pizza just isn’t up to par and they take no pride. I’ve gotten multiple sloppy pizzas that are not even close to what I usually get from Papa John’s. Go to another location stay away from Eagle Mountain!
• PD

  Preston Dean

  Mar 11, 2026
  1.0
  3/11/26: I ordered a takeout pizza with half pepperoni and half another. When I went to pick up the pizza, half of the pizza was missing the pepperoni. I pointed this out to the lady at the front, she appeals to the manager. Manager says he’ll put pepperoni on it and run it back through the oven. 15 mins later, the pizza looks overcooked. I pointed this out to the lady, she appeals to the manager, and the manager says he won’t give me discount. He then tells me it was charged as a half cheese, so I’m already getting a discount. I said no problem if that’s the case. He then says I’m already getting an additional discount because half of a specialty pizza. I said if that’s is the case, no problem. The tone and anger in the voice of the manager however was disrespectful. I understand people make mistakes, but I do not appreciate the poor manner in which I was treated. The pizza is overcooked. Not returning to this location again.
• BR

  Ben Rahlf

  Feb 21, 2026
  5.0
  No complaints here.
• JR

  J Rozzy

  Feb 12, 2026
  2.0
  Long time Papa John's fan and it is normally one of my family's favorites but we were severely disappointed in our experience today. Overall my review would normally be 3.5 stars for this location so instead of giving this a single star which would reflect today's experience I'm giving it two. We ordered at 2 o'clock in the afternoon today and our pizza was VERY doughy… I cannot imagine a valid excuse for this at a period of time during the day where they are probably getting very few orders? Obviously there are either some problems with their oven and temperature settings or even despite it being a slow time of day maybe the workers may have decided to do the old reach in and grab our pizza early from the oven? I don't know but whatever the reason it can't be a good one when I am paying almost $80 for four pizzas… Could have been a really good experience if the pizzas were just cooked for a few minutes longer.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza