Pop-Start Pizza

Reviews

• TT

  Trudy Taillaert

  4 days ago
  5.0
  We found this on maps while we were staying in two Rivers for few days, so we decided to check it out. It's by far the best pizza that we've ever eaten in Wisconsin. So many different special, unique variations of pizzas and the ingredients are all fresh,.. the flavor is amazing. We also had a finger salad that was so delicious..! Anyone coming through this area has to stop in... You won't be disappointed. The owners are so friendly.. we wish we lived closer. .. but for sure we will be back.
• SD

  Shaun Dougherty

  5 days ago
  5.0
  What a great find during our day of antiquing. They had unique pizzas and a fantastic homemade gluten free crust for my wife. The cool decor was fun to look at and the staff was over the top friendly. Good luck and continued success!!
• CM

  Courtney Mueller

  Aug 6, 2026
  5.0
  I get their pizza at least twice a month! My favorites are The NY Marg & the Pony Boy but every single pie Ive tried has been TOP NOTCH. The dough is perfect, the cheese to sauce ratio is so right it can only be described as mathematical. And the service is sucha welcoming vibe.. I love this place
• EW

  Erik Woll

  Aug 1, 2026
  5.0
  Absolutely excellent pizza! Best thing you will eat in manitowoc county hands down! My family eats pizza, a lot, travels for pizza, has celebrated PI(zza) day ever year for over a decade and this pizza is in the top 10 zzas we've had anywhere.
• AF

  Amanda Freeman

  Jul 29, 2026
  5.0
  We stopped in while in town for a family vacation and left wishing we had a Pop-Start pizza near us at home. Do yourselves a favor and try it. This pizza is incredible. Perfect crust. Interesting combinations. Cooked exactly how it should be. We (adults and kids) were all beyond satisfied with our meal. Every bite had us doing a happy dance in our seats. The staff was lovely to chat with. Kind, informative, great recommendations. The entire place, including the cool bathrooms, was spotless. Fun drink options. Convenient location. Fantastic music and theme. 10/10 across the board. We ordered the Pop-peroni, The Spicoli, and The Beastie Boy with a side of cheesy garlic bunkers. Highly, highly recommend all of the above.