Pop-Start Pizza

Reviews

• BS

  Brandon Silvani

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Pizza is super good with a fold type NY style. I’d like an option for squares though. I’m from Racine with genuine Italian style pizza but, your pizza is really good. If I can add, just a little bit mor sauce and crispier crust. With that said, I’ll definitely, without hesitation, buy your pizza again. Dunkers are 👍 btw.
• CR

  Chris Reynolds

  Oct 8, 2026
  5.0
  This is hands down my favorite pizza place in Wisconsin! Justin and Nathan are awesome people, super friendly, easy to talk to, and always make the experience that much better. My wife and I absolutely love their pizzas, and we’re so happy to have found a place this good right around the corner from us! This has officially become our new go to spot, and we couldn’t recommend it more. Great pizza, great people, and a great local business worth supporting! 🙌🍕 Definitely go and check them out!
• RS

  Raul Salmeron

  Oct 2, 2026
  5.0
  Really enjoyed Pop-Start Pizza in Two Rivers! The Neapolitan-style pizza was excellent — fresh, flavorful, with that great charred, blistered crust, and it came out surprisingly quick. The restaurant itself was just as cool. As a Gen Xer, the retro video-game decor and nostalgic atmosphere definitely spoke to me. 🎮 It has a fun personality that you just don't get at the typical pizza place. Great pizza, cool atmosphere, and quick service. Definitely worth stopping in if you're in Two Rivers. Now they just need to start opening locations farther south. Milwaukee, anyone? 🍕
• JN

  Joseph B. Nowak

  Sep 26, 2026
  5.0
  This was absolutely incredible! I'm a local and this is my first time trying it. I love the energetic hip atmosphere with all the 80s movie posters and the pizza of course was incredible! You can taste the quality in every bite. Cheese was very generous and the crust was perfectly cooked, not super doughy but not so thin and hard it will crack your teeth 😂 This is a very different style than your typical bar pizzas (which are good too, don't get me wrong!) if you want an authentic neopolitan style pizza with super high quality ingredients, look no further! This is such a cool operation and I can't wait for my next visit.
• JO

  Jude O.

  Sep 25, 2026
  5.0
  Absolutely incredible pizza! 🍕 This place is the real deal—authentic, fresh, and made with ingredients you can truly taste the quality of. Every bite was bursting with flavor, yet everything tasted so clean and fresh. The crust was perfectly made, the toppings tasted incredibly fresh, and the flavors came together beautifully. You can tell there is real care and passion behind the food. It’s the kind of pizza that doesn’t need to be overloaded with ingredients because the quality speaks for itself. Super delicious, authentic, and simply outstanding! 🍕❤️ We’ve been coming back almost every week. I highly recommend this place to anyone who appreciates real, fresh, delicious pizza!