Silver Coach

Reviews

• OO

  Olas

  Jul 12, 2026
  5.0
  Nice stop for tuna steak and outdoor seating.
• BB

  Bob

  May 23, 2026
  3.0
  Food was good. Service slow. Took like 90 minutes total. Got a fountain drink Got a refill - double charged. $7 for two glasses of coke is not reasonable.
• JD

  Jason Dobbs

  May 17, 2026
  2.0
  The food at Silver Coach was decent. Overall, the food was well-seasoned and the steaks were cooked to order. One of the people in our party did not like the Breast of Chicken Tchoupitoulas - could barely eat it because it was too salty. The prices were high for what they are serving by about $10 per person - it was like paying Madison prices in central Wisconsin. For a party of 5, we ended up paying $300, although this included cocktails and a bottle of Caymus cab ($78). If my wife and I hadn't split our entree, the bill would've been closer to $375. They do NOT do free refills on soda - nickel and dime. The service was not good. No one at the front of the house to seat us for quite some time, even though we had made a reservation. Once we were seated, a couple of things stood out: the wait staff dress like they're about to lounge on the couch - far from what you'd expect in a fine dining experience, the waitress opened our bottle of wine but did not offer to have us taste it our pour it - she just dropped it on the table, and we had to find our own pepper grinder to get pepper on our salads and entrees. The interior is pretty beat up. Instead of feeling quaint, it felt like you were in a trailer park office. The music on the speakers was a radio station - so you'd be eating your $60 steak and drinking your $80 bottle of wine listening to a commercial for a local car dealer. I cannot recommend this restaurant, and will likely not be going back unless I hear that things substantively change, which is a shame because the food was actually pretty good except the one dish.
• EM

  Emily M

  Sep 14, 2021
  5.0
  We wanted to go all out for dinner at least one night on our honeymoon and chose the Silver Coach. We were not disappointed. Friendly staff, pretty and historic setting, good drinks, and amazing food. We had the short ribs as an appetizer; it was so tender you could cut it with a butter knife. We both had one of the steaks on special for our main course and they were cooked to perfect and covered in a delicious sauce. No complaints from either of us, and my husband is very particular about steaks!
• TT

  Ted

  Jul 6, 2018
  4.0
  Fun find - Silver Coach Supper Club - our server Juliet made it a fun visit and offered the private dining room that was formerly a "sleeper" in the original train car - very interesting details in this private dining room for two. In all candor dining at the Silver Coach deserves more time than we really wanted to devote as we were just driving through and ordered from their "lighter fare" portion of the menu. I tried the short rail ribs with fries and she tried the chicken strips with fries - again, probably not what we'd typically order for finer dining. My ribs were delicious, tasty, tangy sauce and her chicken strips were a little dry but tasty enough. We both had Brandy Old fashioneds from the bar and they were excellent. The decor is step back in time, nicely done. The next time we visit, we'll allow more time to soak in the ambiance and enjoy the full supper club experience. Enjoy, we did.

Frequently Asked Questions About Silver Coach