Faye's Pizza

Reviews

• CS

  Cathy Siminow

  May 8, 2026
  3.0
  For years this has been our favorite pizza!!! 5+ rating. Recently, we have gotten several pizzas from pre-bake to frozen and the best pick up or eat in. First, the crust is not crispy like it used to be. It is chewy. Then, the cheese tasted different. The overall pizza is not the same. Hundreds of people say Faye’s has the best pizza. It is a Sheboygan staple. I wish they would leave the best alone. I hope this is just a hiccup. We really miss the old way it was made. If this continues we will be looking for a new favorite.
• AB

  Aubrey Bolton

  Apr 1, 2026
  1.0
  if I could give them 0 stars, I would. So, so disgusting. Service was horrible. For $20+ per pizza, we expected way better but couldn’t even finish most of it because we felt nauseous. I miss the old owners, the new management sucks. The sauce was nasty, and the crust was literally like a cracker. I wish I could get the time I wasted eating this back.
• DT

  David Tran

  Apr 1, 2026
  5.0
  Everything tasted fresh and thoughtfully made, and the flavors really came through in every bite. The atmosphere felt comfortable and laid-back, and the team there was warm and welcoming. Definitely a place I’d come back to.
• NB

  Northern Bear

  Mar 28, 2026
  1.0
  We've been coming here since we were little kids, but within the last few years , We've been getting poor service and poor food. Today I tried ordering a pizza, the first person who took my order gave me a wrong price, then I called back and the second person gave me a different incorrect price compared to the web site. They were very rude. I just ended up canceling because they didn't seem very trustworthy.
• JK

  John Kiener

  Mar 19, 2026
  5.0
  Great tasting pizza, sides, and friendly staff

Frequently Asked Questions About Faye's Pizza