Since 1957, Faye's Pizza has been making pizza the traditional way. We have not changed the way we offer a unique taste from a unique place. We offer dine in, take-out and delivery service in Sheboygan, WI..
For years this has been our favorite pizza!!! 5+ rating. Recently, we have gotten several pizzas from pre-bake to frozen and the best pick up or eat in. First, the crust is not crispy like it used to be. It is chewy. Then, the cheese tasted different. The overall pizza is not the same. Hundreds of people say Faye’s has the best pizza. It is a Sheboygan staple. I wish they would leave the best alone. I hope this is just a hiccup. We really miss the old way it was made. If this continues we will be looking for a new favorite.
AB
Aubrey Bolton
Apr 1, 2026
1.0
if I could give them 0 stars, I would. So, so disgusting. Service was horrible. For $20+ per pizza, we expected way better but couldn’t even finish most of it because we felt nauseous. I miss the old owners, the new management sucks. The sauce was nasty, and the crust was literally like a cracker. I wish I could get the time I wasted eating this back.
DT
David Tran
Apr 1, 2026
5.0
Everything tasted fresh and thoughtfully made, and the flavors really came through in every bite. The atmosphere felt comfortable and laid-back, and the team there was warm and welcoming. Definitely a place I’d come back to.
NB
Northern Bear
Mar 28, 2026
1.0
We've been coming here since we were little kids, but within the last few years , We've been getting poor service and poor food. Today I tried ordering a pizza, the first person who took my order gave me a wrong price, then I called back and the second person gave me a different incorrect price compared to the web site. They were very rude. I just ended up canceling because they didn't seem very trustworthy.
Faye's Pizza is located at 1821 Calumet Drive, Sheboygan, WI 53081, USA.
What are the opening hours of Faye's Pizza?
Faye's Pizza is open Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday 11:00-14:00 and 16:00-20:00; Friday 11:00-14:00 and 16:00-21:00; Saturday 11:00-21:00; Sunday 11:00-19:00; and closed on Tuesday.
Does Faye's Pizza offer delivery service?
Yes, Faye's Pizza offers delivery service in Sheboygan, WI.
What types of food does Faye's Pizza specialize in?
Faye's Pizza specializes in pizza, appetizers, salads, soups, and subs.
What payment methods are accepted at Faye's Pizza?
Faye's Pizza accepts American Express, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa credit cards.
Can I order from Faye's Pizza online?
Yes, you can place orders online at https://fayespizza.alohaorderonline.com/.
Is Faye's Pizza owned by a woman?
Yes, Faye's Pizza is a woman-owned business.
What nearby businesses can I visit along with Faye's Pizza?
Nearby, you can visit LoveLee CheeseCakes bakery for desserts, KWIK TRIP #361 convenience store and gas station for quick supplies, or Nicky's Pizza for another pizza option.
Are there any nearby churches near Faye's Pizza?
Yes, nearby churches include St. Paul Ev. Lutheran Church, St Paul Lutheran Church, Sheboygan Evangelical Free Church, Sheboygan eFree Church, and St John United Church of Christ.
What automotive-related services are near Faye's Pizza?
Nearby automotive-related services include Sheboygan Transmission Service LLC, Goulding Auto for automotive repair and detailing, and U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer for truck rentals.
Brand Certified Facts from Faye's Pizza
This information is certified by Faye's Pizza and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified May 17, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: