Who's on Third

Reviews

• WW

  William William

  1 day ago
  4.0
  This was my second time visiting this restaurant, and it was just as enjoyable as the first 😄🍽️ I still think they serve some of the best cheese curds I’ve ever had 🧀🔥 They’re fresh, perfectly battered, and those giant curds are seriously impressive! Don’t skip the special sauce - it really takes them to the next level 😋👌 The brat options were also phenomenal and full of flavor 🌭✨ This area has so much great food to offer, but this place really stands out for both quality and atmosphere 👍 If you’re in the mood for tasty food in a fun and relaxed environment, you should definitely check out Who’s On Third 🎉🍻
• MD

  Michelle Demopolis

  Apr 26, 2026
  5.0
  You MUST pop in here. The food is fresh, and delicious. The drinks are on point. The staff is so kind. Around the corner from the Hyatt Regency (as their restaurants are closed after breakfast and until dinner). It's a small, personal bar with great food.
• RB

  Robert Bilkie

  Apr 15, 2026
  5.0
  In town from Detroit for a few days of business meetings and stumbled into Who’s on Third—what a great find. The beer selection is outstanding, with plenty of options whether you’re in the mood for something local or just a solid classic. The food was just as impressive—well above what you’d expect from a bar. What really made the experience stand out, though, was the service. Avery behind the bar is a fantastic host—engaging, sharp, and genuinely interesting to talk to. You can tell they enjoy what they do, and it elevates the whole atmosphere. If you’re in Milwaukee, whether for work or just passing through, this place is absolutely worth a stop.
• JH

  Jason H

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  Came solely for the shuttle to the Brewers game, and picked it over other bars because the shuttle logistics were perfectly described on their website. Grabbed a beer from the fast and attentive bartender. The shuttle process was also excellent with the driver announcing shuttle departures multiple times. For an out of towner, it was exactly what I wanted. In my opinion, it is the only way to get to and from a brewers game from downtown. If you have any anxiety about it, don’t. Have a beer, ride the shuttle, enjoy the game
• KS

  Kevin Spaeth

  Apr 10, 2026
  5.0
  I just came back from a conference at Baird Center. We discovered Who's On Third the first night. Avery and Kat were awesome. We made friends with one of the locals, Orian and played bar dice. Avery said they were the best wings in town but the fryers had been shut down by then. It was such a good night for the rest of the conference we said "all roads lead to (Who's on) Third". That was our meeting spot for when everyone was done with their events or dinners. I learned to cook by make chicken wings in the early 90s. I knew I had to try some. So me and a few dudes snuck away from a bland conference lunch and went over. Avery was the bartender for the lunch shift. I took her suggestion of 6 honey bacon and 6 schiracha ginger. They were fantastic. Turns out Averys boyfriend grew up where I was cooking wings in Jersey and knew the joint. His mom might have gone to Seton Hall with my older brother. That's how friendly and nice she was We talked about cool things. We closed the bar down that night. Great old fashions! The conference ended at noon the next day so another bunch of us went back for more wings and loaded tots before heading to the airport