Benny's Café

Reviews

• SK

  Susan Kraft

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Nice place to relax, talk and enjoy ourselves. Great food.
• IG

  Isaac Graycarek

  4 days ago
  5.0
  The breakfast here was very good, but the service was outstanding. Our waitress was running over from one end of the restaurant to the other for the customers. Very appreciative of the work she had done. Can’t wait to come back and enjoy the food once again
• SC

  Scott Carson

  Aug 28, 2026
  5.0
  I can’t believe I’ve never stopped in here before. It was fantastic. The food is tasty and fresh! The servers are kind and attentive! Brittany, my server, made this such a great experience! I can’t wait to come back and bring my wife
• CL

  Cliffe Lawton

  Aug 28, 2026
  5.0
  Great food, big selection, the waitstaff are fantastic, the atmosphere is very nice. We love going there when we visit Milwaukee
• LG

  Laura Garcia

  Aug 15, 2026
  1.0
  Horrible Horrible service, Owner was my main contact, very rude. I called to order a BLT, he said i could not order because the soup wasn’t ready and it automatically comes with the soup and that I would have to wait until 11am. I asked to replace soup with anything else and he said no, I asked to just get the sandwich and he said no. I then told him that I would pick up at 11 so it can come with the soup since it’s supposedly MANDATORY that it comes with a soup?? He then proceeded to tell me the total was a bit over 17$?? On the menu it quite literally says that with tax it should be no more than $15. So on top of the rude customer service and ridiculous mandatory soup rules, they also upcharge for answering the phone?? Do not recommend this place, quality and customer service has gone down hill ever since Benny sold this establishment.