Garlic Bread
$3.99
Italian bread topped with buttery garlic butter.
Brand Certified
Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville
Certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville • Aug 16, 2026
Business Details
2107 E. Vincent Rd., Milton, WI
53563, United States
Certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville • Aug 16, 2026
(608) 580-0059
Certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville • Aug 16, 2026
http://pizzapit.biz/milton
Certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville • Aug 16, 2026
About
Certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville • Aug 16, 2026
Pizza RestaurantChicken Wings RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceSandwich Restaurant
Milton Pizza Pit is a renowned pizza restaurant that has been serving delicious pizza since 1969 in Wisconsin. They take pride in their commitment to using fresh ingredients and making their dough and sauce from scratch every day. With their real Wisconsin pizza cheese blend, they aim to provide the best pizza in the region. In addition to pizza, Milton Pizza Pit offers a variety of other menu items such as chicken wings, hot sandwiches, appetizers, and more. Milton Pizza Pit has gained recognition for their quality and taste. In 2025, Pizza Pit was voted as the Best Pizza, Best Chicken Wings, and Best Lunch by the Wisconsin State Journal and Madison.com. Delivery to Milton, Edgerton, and Newville.
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Accepts reservationsNot available
- Requires reservationsNot available
Location
Certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville • Aug 16, 2026
Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville
2107 E. Vincent Rd., Milton, WI
53563, United States
Hours
Certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville • Aug 16, 2026
Monday4:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Tuesday4:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday4:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Thursday4:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Friday4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Menu
1 menu · 73 items
Explore offerings from Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville on 2107 E. Vincent Rd. in Milton, with popular appetizers, classic pizza, specialty pizzas, and pizza twins available at this location.
Milton/Edgerton Pizza Pit Menu
73 items
Appetizers
Cheese Bread
$4.99
Garlic Bread topped with mozarella cheese.
Breadstix
$4.99 - $6.49
Freshly baked breadsticks smothered in garlic butter and topped with parmesan cheese. Your choice of dipper sauce(s). 4 piece with 1 dipping sauce $4.99 or 6 pieces with 2 dipping sauces $6.49.
Bosco Sticks
$6.49 - $7.49
Cheese filled breadstix, baked to perfection. Your choice of dipper sauce(s). 4 piece with 1 dipping sauce $6.49 or 6 piece with 2 dipping sauces $7.49.
Cheese Curds
$7.99
9 oz. breaded fried cheese curds
Deep fried Mushroom
$6.99
Jalapeno Poppers
$7.99
6 jalapeno poppers
Onion Rings
$6.99
French Fries
$4.29
Almost a pound of Homestyle French Fries.
Mac & Cheese Bites
$7.49
Creamy macaroni filled wedges in a crispy batter (8 Count)
Spicy Pickle Fries
$7.99
Crispy, tangy thin-cut pickle fries lightly coated in a premium cornmeal and spicy mustard batter. Served with ranch.
Athens Gyros
Tender slices of our select, hand-carved lamb and beef, broiled on a vertical skewer with imported Mediterranean spices, Chicken or Veggie. Piled onto a warm pita bread, smothered with onions, tomatoes and our special homemade tzatziki sauce. Athens Gyros (Your Choice of Lamb & Beef, Chicken)
Athens Gyro
$11.49
Tender slices of hand-carved lamb and beef, broiled on a vertical skewer and piled onto a warm pita bread, smothered with onions, tomatoes, and our homemade tzatziki sauce.
Athens Gyro Plate
$14.99
Extra of our Athens Gyro meat, plus Homestyle French Fries.
Athens Chicken Gyro
$11.49
Chicken piled onto a warm pita bread and smothered with onions, tomatoes, and our homemade tzatziki sauce.
Extra of our Chicken meat, plus Homestyle French Fries.
Pit Stix
Fresh handmade crust with garlic butter, mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Sprinkled with parmesan and Italian seasoning. Cut in strips and served with dipper sauces. Extra dipper sauces are only $0.95 each. Gluten Free option available as 12" Medium.
Medium 12"
$12.99
Fresh handmade crust with garlic butter, mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Sprinkled with parmesan and Italian seasoning. Cut in strips and served with 2 dipper sauces.
Large 14"
$14.99
Fresh handmade crust with garlic butter, mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Sprinkled with parmesan and Italian seasoning. Cut in strips and served with 2 dipper sauces.
Extra Large 16"
$16.99
Fresh handmade crust with garlic butter, mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Sprinkled with parmesan and Italian seasoning. Cut in strips and served with 3 dipper sauces.
Chicken & Fish
Award winning chicken wings. Comes with your favorite dipper sauce(s). Try our Seafood dinners and Chicken dinners.
1 Pound of meaty delicious chicken wings. Comes with 1 dipper sauce.
1 1/2 pounds meaty delicious chicken wings. Comes with 2 dipper sauces.
1 pound of meaty and delicious chicken drummies. Comes with 1 dipper sauce.
1 1/2 pounds of meat and delicious chicken drummies. Comes with 2 dipper sauces.
3/4 pound of Boneless Chicken Wings with 1 dipper sauce. Extra dipper sauces are $0.95 each.
1 pound boneless chicken wings with 2 dipper sauces.
3/4 pound of large chicken breast fillets with 1 dipper sauce.
1 pound of tender chicken strips. Comes with 2 dipper sauces.
Chicken Strip Dinner
$11.49
4 chicken strips with dipping sauce includes coleslaw & French fries.
Comes with coleslaw, French fries, and tartar sauce.
Dipper Sauces
$0.95
Tangy BBQ, Ranch Dressing, Dijon BBQ, Bleu Cheese, Sweet & Sour, Nacho Cheese, Pizza Sauce, Hot Buffalo Sauce, Garlic Butter, Mango Habanero, Chipotle Ranch, Honey Mustard, & Hot Honey (NEW).
Pig Wings
$12.99
3/4 pound (5-6 count). Pig wings are a delicious and all natural product made from the pork shank. A single bone surrounded by lean, tender meat. looks like chicken, tastes like ribs. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
1 Pound chicken wings and drummies The Heat is in the Meat. Comes with 1 dipper sauce,
Big Dipper Inferno Wings
$14.99
1.5 pounds chicken wings and drummies. The Heat is in the Meat. Comes with 2 dipper sauces.
Subs
Comes with a bag of potato chips & pickle spear.
Layers of salami, pepperoni & ham
Meatball With Cheese
$8.99
Beefy meatballs simmered in our pizza sauce, topped with green pepperes, onian and cheese
Ham & Cheese
$8.99
Ham topped with cheese
Pepperoni & Ham
$8.99
Just like it sounds. Ham & Pepperoni, Topped with cheese.
Veggie Sub
$8.99
Tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese. Comes with pickle spear and bag of Lay's potato chips.
Desserts
Assorted flavors
8" Brownie
$7.29
8" warm brownie
Pizza Cookie
$7.29
Pizza Cookie
Sugar Donuts (Beignets)
$3.99 - $5.29
Filled with Chocolate and Caramel
Beverages
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville
Do you have GLP-1 friendly options?
Yes, we do. Try a thin & crispy pizza crust with light cheese then top with your favorite vegetable and/or chicken. Another option is our Athen's Chicken Gyro without a pita or half a pita.
Do you offer a gluten free crust?
Yes, we offer a Medium 12" gluten free crust. It is prepared in same kitchen as our other food.
Are large order allowed outside of business hours?
Yes, please call the store to find out if a large order outside of normal hours is possible.
Does Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville accept reservations?
No, Pizza Pit does not accept reservations.
Can I order Pizza Pit menu items for delivery or pickup?
Yes, you can order for both in-store pickup and delivery.
What are the typical opening hours for Pizza Pit - Milton?
Pizza Pit is open weekdays from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM and weekends starting at 11:00 AM with closing times between 8:00 PM and 9:00 PM.
Does Pizza Pit offer gluten free pizza crust?
Yes, they offer a Medium 12" gluten free crust prepared in the same kitchen as other food.
Are large orders allowed outside of normal business hours?
Yes, large orders outside normal hours may be possible by calling the store to arrange.
What types of payment does Pizza Pit accept?
They accept American Express, Cash, Contactless Payments, MasterCard, and Visa.
Does Pizza Pit serve alcohol including beer?
Yes, Pizza Pit serves alcohol including beer but does not have an onsite bar.
What are some nearby bars and restaurants where customers can go after dining at Pizza Pit?
Nearby options include 59er Bar and Grill, The Kosh Kabin Bar and Grill, Milton Roadhouse, Beach Club, and Pettit's Lakeview Campground and Bar, which are great for drinks or socializing after your meal.
How can customers visiting Pizza Pit use nearby places for convenience?
Customers can visit Kosh Liquors nearby for convenience items or beverages to complement their Pizza Pit meal.
Are there any nearby recreational options for customers who want to enjoy nature after their meal?
Yes, customers can visit nearby campgrounds such as Wishman Retreat, Lakeland Camping Resort, Lakeland Campground, and Pettit's Lakeview Campground and Bar for outdoor recreation.
Brand Certified Facts from Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville
This information is certified by Pizza Pit - Milton / Edgerton / Newville and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 16, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website