El Pastor Mexican Restaurant

Reviews

• AR

  Allison Renzi

  Apr 28, 2026
  4.0
  Standard seating for the average Mexican restaurant. We went around 245 in the afternoon after spending the day at the zoo so it wasn't busy. Service was prompt and friendly and to be honest thos place had the best Chile Rellano that I've had in Wisconsin having lived in central Wisconsin for 14 yrs now. My Paramore had a margarita which was good but didn't have the customary ring of salt on the lip of the glass. The rice and beans were average for mid afternoon on a weekday. But they get a lot of points in the plus for the Chile Relleno
• FG

  Frankl J García

  Apr 24, 2026
  4.0
  Es un restaurante con un excellent menu y con un servicio muy bueno y lo que me sorprendio es que tiene precios muy buenos en cada platillos y el personal es muy chido te lo recomiendo si gustas pasar un rato tranquilo y si gustas probar gastronomia Mexican
• PS

  Peggy Scallon

  Mar 30, 2026
  5.0
  We had them cater a birthday party at our house. The food was tasty and hearty. Abundant portions. They set it up beautiful and it was a hit for our party. Lino and our delivery person were also great to work with.
• ZZ

  Zu Ekpunobi (Dr. Zu)

  Feb 23, 2026
  4.0
  3.5 - 4 out of 5 doesn't mean bad but it's appropriate for the level of quality here. Food/service is fast, comes with starter nachos, and portion sizes are good. That said, mango margarita was unfortunately bitter, food presentation was very basic and ambience of the place was lacking. Food was good, not great and items in my order were wrong (asked for flour tortillas specifically, got corn). The lack of attention to detail is PayPal not it's ok for a quick bite.
• RZ

  Reba Zaidi

  Feb 5, 2026
  5.0
  Gordita with chicken and avocado REALLY good. Ready in 15 minutes for pick up.