Colectivo Coffee On the Square

Reviews

• MH

  Matthew Hindle

  Jul 15, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered a coffee and strawberry rhubarb parfait. They got my name wrong and I was waiting ages while it was apparently sitting on the side with me waiting like an idiot in a empty restaurant (why wouldn't she tell me this? I'm standing right in front of her??). I assumed they hadn't heard my order the first time and I reordered the parfait. Then I realised the brown paper package sitting there was the original order. So the whole experience of this place was expensive, having paid twice, and thoroughly unpleasant. I'll stick with the marigold for breakfast.
• KB

  Killian Beck

  Jun 19, 2026
  5.0
  Everything I've tried here is delicious. I love getting decaf and half-caff lattes and mochas. Had an oat milk London Fog with their Jasmine tea instead of Earl Grey and the avocado toast. Both were superb. Nice vibes and good energy inside the store. Lots of space to hang out. Very clean. Great location. The baristas are all friendly and highly skilled. Good prices. The bathroom was very clean. Another lovely part of my experience today: I heard one of my favorite songs off of one of my all time favorite albums: Atlas Sound - Walkabout (w/ Noah Lennox) off of Logos, (2009). Highly, highly recommend listening to the whole album. Every song on it slaps. Easily an s-tier album. If I were forced to rank it, I would definitely put it in the top 10 all time favorite albums of mine. Maybe even top 5...
• TS

  Tommie Starich

  May 10, 2026
  1.0
  I began getting my Coffee at Colectivo because their competitor Starbucks began a hateful policy of judging a person’s worthiness to use their bathroom by if they had a paper cup in their hand. LUCILLE & COOPERS TAVERN AND THE OLD FASHIONED & many other businesses are not locking down bathrooms and restricting or judging customers value before letting them use a bathroom. Is this hateful policy how you want your mom or dad to be treated? No excuses for Colectivo or Starbucks. If Colectivo wants to judge if gramma is worth letting her use the bathroom. Colectivo won’t get my business or my tips. It wasn’t always this way and we still have people friendly coffee shops if COLECTIVO wants to establish hateful money focused policies. They can’t have my tips or business. I bought my last cup of coffee today at Colectivo and won’t ever go to any Colectivo location ever again.
• FF

  flavio

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  my favorite café in Madison. the only thing i'd suggest them to improve is that in the summer it might paradoxically be too cold to stay there. all the rest (coffee, food, location, atmosphere, is top class)
• SS

  sri krishna Seshadri

  Apr 26, 2026
  5.0
  Great coffee. Great location. Wonderful staff. Pricey yes but worth it for the location. Especially when it's 70 out!! Highly recommended.

Frequently Asked Questions About Colectivo Coffee On the Square