Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Reviews

• AW

  Alex W

  1 day ago
  1.0
  Rude lady answering the phone tonight. Why do they seem mad you are placing an order to go every time I call?
• AN

  AJ Niebler

  2 days ago
  5.0
  During my visit I ordered the tomato basil soup and potato cream soup. Both those soups were above my expectations and the cheese chunks added to the tomato basil were perfect. Both soups were thicker, filled with flavor that didn’t overpower the main ingredients. For the main dishes I ordered spicy penne (2 meatballs) and the creamy tomato Alfredo (1 sausage 1 meatball). Both these dishes come with meat balls or their homemade sausage. I HIGHLY suggest getting the sausage, honestly I enjoyed every bite and it had a nice spiciness with a great firmness and wasn’t extremely greasy or salty. The meatballs however I did not enjoy as much. It was a slightly sweeter flavor and dense. I’m glad I did not order the meatball sub as my preferences for flavor wouldn’t have matched what I expected. To note, I did try one with the spicy marinara and one with the creamy tomato Alfredo. For those asking about portions, they were filling, the server undersold the main dishes but was spot on with describing the amount you’d get for soups so when the food arrived I was pleasantly surprised and stuffed by the end. Anticipate a larger meal than the photos for this restaurant show, During however and why I give 5 stars is during my visit there was an issue that came up with my food that I believe was beyond anyones reasonable control. The staff took the issue seriously and I commend them for their efforts! I feel comfortable knowing that I could select anything on this menu and it was prepared by people who care. Thank you for a great dinner and I would return.
• TM

  Timothy Miller

  Jul 19, 2026
  1.0
  I drove a half hour just to try their pizza, it cost $45 for a 16", drove a half hour home and it was burnt badly
• PS

  Perry Scanlan

  Jul 16, 2026
  5.0
  The pizza was really good. We had three different pizzas and all of them were amazing. Friendly staff and attentive service.
• KP

  Kim Pigeon

  Jun 30, 2026
  5.0
  As soon as you walk in the door, you are greeted with the aroma of fresh oldvworld pizza. The thin crust is perfectly crisp, with enough sauce and toppings to satisfy. We love the flavors. The staff are super helpful and provide excellent service. I can see why it is a favorite in Green Bay! Try the antipasto salad, you won't be disappointed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant