Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Green Bay

Reviews

• II

  Imelda

  May 7, 2026
  3.0
  Me and my husband have been here before and it was good. This time wasn’t so good. We ordered takeout ahead of time and waited around 25 minutes for our food. We thought waiting that much time our food would come out hot and good… Chicken was gross and chewy in a bad way. Broccoli was undercooked and the noodles were lukewarm. Not happy with my experience, they also got our order wrong. We ordered one Alfredo with no chicken and one with chicken and they gave us both with chicken. They also forgot to add forks to our takeout bag.. :( Also to add the guy was on his phone scrolling while we were asking him for forks.. unprofessional..
• MM

  Michelle Mann

  Apr 27, 2026
  2.0
  The food is fine if you like the taste of Dominos (I do). My biggest gripe is that I ordered a "vegg out" pizza and didn't get it. I am sure of it because I went back to the web page I ordered and it 100% said "vegg out". Upon returning home the pizza had huge wedges of potato. Looking back at my receipt, the order changed after I had checked out. It kept the changes I made (square cut, thick crust), but changed the type of pizza. What kind of nonsense is that? The pizza was called "wedge fry classic". That's not even on the menu lmao
• PQ

  Pel Qel

  Apr 21, 2026
  3.0
  This review combines both my experience at the Green Bay location, as well as my sister's recent experience in Appleton. Both of us have been longtime fans/customers of Glass Nickel pizza, but something has happened to the quality of their pizzas in the last 3 years or so... It is nowhere near as good as it used to be. I heard there was an ownership/management change around 2022, but I can't confirm this. Either way, toppings have suffered in quality, and the amount of certain toppings on their pizzas have become so sparse that it would be laughable until you think about the amount of money that you just paid! My last 3 times getting 16" pizzas delivered have been VERY disappointing, and my sister's recent corporate lunch order of over $100 for a group was likewise extremely perplexing. We are never ordering from them again - it is too sad. Dominos is better - and I rate Dominos a "straight C".
• RR

  Risu

  Apr 12, 2026
  5.0
  When my husband and I want pizza, we come here. Food and service has always been excellent. My only complaint is that I wish they'd add artichokes as a topping choice.
• KJ

  Kenny & JJ

  Mar 21, 2026
  3.0
  Food was pretty good, but pizza was a little greasy, ravioli was slightly over cooked. It was pretty dead but still took a while for food. Server was alright, he was friendly but wasn't efficient. Pretty good overall. Would come again.

Frequently Asked Questions About Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Green Bay