Antica Sicilia

Reviews

• DK

  Devani Killpack

  2 days ago
  5.0
  My fiancé took me here for my birthday and it was phenomenal. I’ve been excited to try it for a long time and it lived up to every expectation and then some. Our server Luigi was wonderful, friendly, attentive, and showed joy and passion for the work and the quality food he was serving. I will definitely be going again when I have some extra money to treat myself to a delicious meal. Also, the carbonara is their famous dish for a reason. Absolutely the best pasta I’ve ever had. And the free cannoli for my birthday tied everything together perfectly.
• OV

  Odalis Vargas

  5 days ago
  5.0
  The food, atmosphere, service and staff are amazing! Some of the best food I’ve ever had in my life. I loved the sun-dried tomato pesto. It’s a simple complimentary dish that exceeded our expectations and was so yummy to eat. The entrees and drinks were amazing as well, wish I had more room in my stomach for more of their food. Faye was our server and she was amazing! Since it was our first time there, we felt unsure of what to order. Faye made us feel welcomed and answered all our our questions with ease. She gave great recommendations on food and drinks. She constantly checked in on us and was always aware of plates needing to be cleared and waters refilled. Other staff members were also as attentive and had great services as well! Loved our time there and we will definitely be coming back! Definitely get a dish that is cooked in front of you! I didn’t choose one and I wish I had done it. Will be choosing one the next time I go!!
• DB

  dminic best

  5 days ago
  5.0
  The food here is honestly the best experience that I have ever had at a restaurant. The tomato pesto was out of this world especially seeing as it was a complimentary appetizer. Our waitress Faye was outstanding, she was always there when we needed her but gave us ample room so it never felt overbearing. She also gave exquisite recommendations for the food and drink choices, everything that she recommended was top tier and exactly what we were craving. For the main course I got the bolognese which was advertised as a labor of love that has been slow simmering for hours and let me tell you, I could taste the love and passion that was put into our food. The drink I got was a twist on a Moscow mule where they put in limoncello and let me tell you it was a combination I never knew I needed, the acidity and slight sweetness for the lemon offset the bitterness of the vodka and the spices of the ginger beer. Honestly the only bad thing I can say about this restaurant is that it has ruined all other restaurants for me and I find myself disappointed by new and old places I’ve been because it can’t live up to the standard that Antica Sicilia has set for me. The atmosphere, the waiting staff, and the food are all top tier and I recommend this place to anyone who wants to be absolutely blown away.
• BC

  Brad Crist

  5 days ago
  2.0
  Good food, but the service and billing practices need serious work. We experienced a comedy of errors with our water service. Staff mixed sparkling water into our still water glasses, dumped them out, and continually opened new bottles while we had mostly full ones on the table. I flagged this to our server, Riri, who promised she had "taken care of it." I trusted her, but checked my receipt at home only to find we were charged for 5 bottles of water ($45 with tax and tip) when we drank half of that at most. On top of that, we barely saw our server. It took 30 minutes for her to return to take our entree order after we ordered appetizers, and another 30+ minutes after we ate to get our check at the end of the night. We could have easily freed up our table 45 minutes earlier for the people waiting in the lobby. Disappointing.
• BL

  Bryan Larson

  Aug 11, 2026
  5.0
  I can't even begin to describe how happy I am that we found this place. My dad was visiting from out of town and a few friends recommended that we check out this spot. He had just gotten back from Italy last week and said that this food was BETTER than Italy itself. This restaurant is a major standout as it does EVERYTHING well. First off, our waiter Ehsan was amazing. I truly believe Iranians and Canadians have to be the two nicest groups of people on the planet and Ehsan was no exception to this. He was very detailed about the restaurant and offered some great suggestions as it had been our first time there. Ehsan was so professional and we couldn't have asked for a better server. Antica Sicilia knows how to set the mood. Right when you sit down they bring you fresh bread and I don't know what they did, but they had this tomato sourdough bread that was unlike anything I've had before. That set the tone for the night and we knew we were in for a good night. We started with a Caesar salad that was made tableside and that was just such a solid touch that turned this experience from a fantastic dining experience to an entertainment experience as well. Honestly was one of the best Caesar salads that I have had as well. The next appetizer up were the meatballs and my goodness those were incredible. We also decided to order the carbonara dish as an appetizer too which again was made in a cheese wheel and added to the whole entertainment aspect of the night. Next the entres continued to live up to the whole experience of the night. The branzino was unlike a traditional branzino. It was even better. I've never had a branzino that good in my entire life. We also ordered the gnocchis al formaggio and those were great too. My girlfriend ordered the bolognaise and said it was fantastic! These guys know how to run a restaurant the chef/owner, Giuseppe, went around to all the tables greeting the customers and having genuine conversations. He got into a great conversation with my dad and by the end of the night, we felt like a part of the family. There are few restaurants that can offer an experience like this. Not only from Ehsan and Giuseppe, but the entire staff, even the bus girl from Nashville (whose name slips my mind). She took the time out of her busy day to have a human connection and talk to us. I can't tell you how much I appreciate this restaurant. Not only will I be back, I will be telling everyone that his is a MUST visit.