Supremo Pizza

Reviews

• PH

  Pete Hines

  4 days ago
  5.0
  From NYC. I have been out west 25 yrs. Never really am I consistently impressed with NY style out here. I love this place. So blessed it’s right down the road. They cook it long enough and it has that crispy chewy at the same time thing NY pizza is known for.
• AR

  Alicia Robinson

  May 13, 2026
  5.0
  Great find! Not usually a fan of NY style pizza but Supremo has converted me into a believer. Great toppings, great flavor combos, great dough. Definitely our new favorite spot for pizza.
• CV

  Chris Vastardis

  May 9, 2026
  5.0
  This is some of the best pizza we’ve had in Salt Lake area. Definitely the best in Midvale, our teenage son, & his friends, my wife, my self and my mother-in-law all absolutely loved the pizzas we had & the chicken wings are out of this world. Crust is so crispy perfect and the pizza wasn’t greasy or too cheesy. 9/10 for us all
• JM

  Jackie Mendelson

  May 4, 2026
  1.0
  My my Hawaiian pizza was the worst pizza I have ever seen!! It had almost NO cheese and next to no no ham and pineapple. This place is unbelievably bad!!! Don’t waste your time and money!
• SP

  Scott Plamondon

  Apr 24, 2026
  5.0
  Let me just say - this is the only place and I mean only place you should order or eat pizza from in the entire state of utah - especially if you’re from the east coast! I’m from NY / RI and pizza in the state of utah is absolutely trash except for Supremo - just trust me and order the pizza and wings you won’t be disappointed I promise!