Magnolia Bakery

Reviews

• FF

  Finicky Foodie

  1 day ago
  4.0
  Very cute place! We tried the classic banana pudding and the magic cookie bar and both were tasty, but also so super thick and rich that we couldn’t even finish them. I’m not exactly sure what all the hype is about. It was just good, not amazing. Seems like trendy things aren’t always the actual best things. Just my thoughts…
• DT

  Damita Tovar

  5 days ago
  2.0
  Ordered through DoorDash. The cake was barely mid. It was described as a rich vanilla cake with a decadent chocolate buttercream. The cake wasn’t rich and tasted like a store bought sponge cake. It was dry and crumbly. The chocolate frosting was kind of thin and not decadent. The banana pudding was nothing special. I’ve made similar ones at home. Was expecting more for the hype of this place but maybe it was an off night for them
• LG

  Lorena Gonzalez

  Aug 6, 2026
  5.0
  We tried a few items..the Key Lime Icebox Bar, Blueberry Jamboree, Banana Pudding and a Fully Loaded Icebox Bar and they were all so delicious. My favorite was definitely the Key Lime one..so creamy and not too sweet.
• CP

  Caitlan Pollock

  Aug 4, 2026
  5.0
  I ordered a birthday 🎂 cake for my 40th birthday and boy did Magnolia Bakery deliver! The staff member that took my order was so thorough and friendly. When I picked up my order it was packaged with such care and service I was blown away. I almost cried when I saw the cake because it was perfect, exactly what I wanted! The cake was delicious and for a great price. Couldn't recommend enough!!
• LH

  Lamont H

  Jul 19, 2026
  5.0
  Magnolia Bakery in Holliday, Utah, offers a delightful experience with its friendly and enthusiastic staff who make you feel warmly welcomed from the moment you arrive. The bakery boasts an impressive selection of treats, including cupcakes, sliced cakes, cream cheese brownies, and the much-talked-about banana pudding and key lime ice box bars. During my visit, I couldn't resist the carrot cake and cream cheese brownie, both of which were as delicious as expected. The outdoor patio provided a perfect setting for our group to enjoy these treats comfortably. My friend’s choice, the banana pudding, was exceptional and truly a must-try, evoking nostalgic memories of Southern hospitality and flavors from Georgia. Overall, Magnolia Bakery has created a winning combination of great service, tasty desserts, and a welcoming atmosphere. I’m already looking forward to returning for another taste of that unforgettable banana pudding. Thank you