KC
Kate Cavanaugh
1 day ago
I love the location off 46 but I will not be going to this location again. I called ahead for two personal pizzas one on a cauliflower crust. Then I went in for pick up 20 minutes later and was advised that one of the pizzas was made on regular crust so they had to redo it. No problem with that… I waited 20 more minutes before walking up and asking what the status was on the pizzas. The guy at the counter just said oh yeah, and grabbed the two pizzas out of the warmer where they clearly had been for a while. He didn’t open them up or anything and continue to help other customers then I reminded him that I hadn’t paid and so I paid for the two pizzas. Upon getting in the car, I opened my pizzas and realized that the cauliflower crust was not provided on the redo either. Instead, they cooked it on a gluten-free crust, which is fine, but not what I ordered and they also burnt it to a crisp so it tasted terrible, and I ended up throwing the whole pizza away. This was also at 3 o’clock on a Sunday so they were not crowded. Ended up wasting money and time
David was super cool even though I ordered right before 9pm, what a great guy, thank you, fantastic service
LM
Lisa Morris
Jun 21, 2026
Mattenga's Pizzeria in New Braunfels is fabulous, it is perfect thin crust pizza that taste delicious. I tried the Supreme - Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, and Black Olives. It was yummy yum. I also tried The Margherita - Tomatoes, fresh Basil oil, red sauce and Mozzarella so delicious. The atmosphere of the Restaurant is wonderful, both inside and out. Customer Service is excellent by Adam, Wyatt, Matt,and Enga, they were very helpful and friendly.
Its a good thing there is a gym across the parking lot with how often I am going to be eating here!
The spicy peach wings are a must try!
CH
Col. Ron Hall
Jun 15, 2026
We went to the brand new Mattengas off of business 35 in the parking lot of the outlet mall. We were greeted by a very friendly manager, who informed me that it's was only their 3rd day of operation. I've never tried one of these pizzas, so I ordered one (the loaded one). I am so glad that I did! This pizza is very flavorful, well-loaded, and sported a thinner than most crust which was perfect. This is, by far, the best pizza that I've had in many years. Its so refreshing to know that quality such as this is out there. Thanks to the staff for making this a great dining experience. We'll be back often! Col. Ron