Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels

Reviews

• KJ

  Kelsey Jaeger

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Top tier pizza. Definitely our newest favorite pizza place in town. Downloaded the app are already used my points for free pizza rolls! Excellent
• BK

  B Koch

  1 day ago
  5.0
  It was our first time getting pizza from here & we had it delivered. Our food arrived earlier than promised and tasted like it just came out of the oven! We wanted to try the margharita pizza so got the 10” for 10.99 and got the 20” all meat pizza. Both pizzas were fantastic! Fresh ingredients and so flavorful! The 20” pizza was huge so we will be having pizza for breakfast! Great price, great food and awesome delivery customer service!
• JS

  Josh Shapiro

  May 9, 2026
  5.0
  The food is really good. Above & beyond service from Noah at the front counter. We ate in the restaurant and it wasn't just us getting great service. He was putting in effort with every customer who walked through the door. He was remembering people's names who were returning customers and making sure every person was being taken care of and getting exactly what they ordered and were satisfied with what they were getting. Great employees make four happy customers on repeat business.
• FG

  Fredrick Gulledge

  May 2, 2026
  5.0
  Almost weekly customer here. Food is always fresh and tasty. Keep up the good work on that front. Service is spoit on. Friendly, quick, what more do you need? Nothing! Now let's talk website. Need to give some attention to the details. Last several times I ordered artichokes. We'll. I couldn't understand how I get charged and they never show up. Found out tonight, there are none! Ugh! Ok, let's talk salads. Neither greek or garden salad are pictured with pepperoncinis. However, the website permits you to check No Pepperoncinis. We'll, to a customer ordering on line that would me the salad comes with them. Uh, no. Want to add them? No, again. No option to select. Now I am thinking the pepperoncinis left with the artichokes..! Since I am being picky about the website, need to decide to go with "NO" or "No" under the changes section. Also, TEXAS Ranch or Texas Pothole Pizza? That cap key is killing your web designer. Consitency is paramount. I know it small, but it is reprinting the brand! (I didn't look over the entire website, so I might recommend a full review.) The food is great and reasonable! Keep up the good work! See you next week!
• LM

  LL Michelle.

  Apr 30, 2026
  5.0
  We live in Schertz And have always ordered our pizzas from the Schert location. Today we just happen to be in the new Braunfels area and saw that there was a location here. And what do you know we were in the Mood for pizza. When we walked in the door, we were greeted by a huge smile And a sweet warm personality. His name is Noah. He was super patient with my son as he ordered his specialized pizza, helping him make his choices and showing not one bit of frustration. As we sat on the bench outside waiting, he even brought Our to go pizza out to us and If it was satisfactory. To no surprise it was perfect just like this warm small very homelike welcoming location. I will drive the extra miles for great customer service.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels