I've been here a few times. The pizza is fine. The issue is the price. If I'm paying $20 for a large pizza I want the quality of it to be commensurate with the price. The pizzas to me taste like Dominos, Pizza Hut, or Papa john's where I can save $9. So aside from it being a small biz and not a corporation, I would go elsewhere....because of the price.
Went with my wife and son and sat inside to eat. Exceptional service, everyone was so nice and friendly. They even gave my kiddo a few quarters to get something from the machine, which was a sincere and kind gesture that was entirely unexpected. The pizza was excellent. We had a wonderful experience. We will most definitely be back to this location, and hope that the owner of this fine establishment sees our review and knows that they have exceptional employees who are truly kind, professional and courteous. Thank you for a great dining experience!
JB
Justin Bereiter
Sep 29, 2026
Great pizza with even better service. Walking into Mattenga’s for the first time and will return. Noah the manager (if not the manager promote immediately) welcomed us into the store. When we said this is the first time there, he explained the menu, what they can do, and pizza sizes. Deciding on the 16” 50/50 pizza we got supreme and the Texas pothole. The pizza was delicious, lots of toppings and the crust was amazing. Believe me, get the pothole it’s good and this is coming from someone that lived in Italy. And for those worried about the cost, the 16” was $25. Again worth it.
JQ
Joel Quintanilla
Sep 28, 2026
We’ve been to Mattenga’s Pizzeria on Hwy 46 a couple of times now, and both visits have been fantastic! The service has been excellent, the atmosphere is great, and the pizza is seriously delicious! 🍕🔥
A HUGE shoutout to Ryan for taking such great care of us! He was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. Great service like that really makes a difference.
If you’re looking for great pizza and awesome service in New Braunfels, definitely give Mattenga’s a try. We’ll absolutely be back!
CH
Cutco Henry
Sep 15, 2026
Listen carefully, Internet.
I am not a dramatic man.
I do not cry at commercials.
I have never once claimed a restaurant “changed my life.”
Until last night, when Mattenga’s Pizzeria in New Braunfels performed a miracle so pure and perfect it deserves its own national holiday.
We ordered like responsible adults:
-One half-cheese / half-pepperoni for the small, sticky-handed dictators who still believe crust is a personal attack
-One Honey Bexar (cup-and-char pepperoni, jalapeños, and that sweet-hot honey drizzle that tastes like a Texas sunset decided to throw a private party on a perfect crust)
-One Santa Fe (pepperoni, bacon, and Hatch green chiles so flawless I briefly considered naming my next child “Hatch”)
-Two sacred vessels of ranch: Mattenga’s Ranch and Texas Ranch, because a pizza without proper dipping sauce is simply incomplete
Then I casually mentioned I’d leave a good review... What happened next can only be described as divine intervention with extra cheese.
An entire order of pizza rolls appeared at my door unannounced, unsolicited, and overflowing with pure generosity. They arrived like a gift from the pizza gods themselves. I opened the bag and actually whispered, “Who do I thank for this level of kindness, and how many more orders will it take to properly express my gratitude?”
And the delivery drivers?
These heroes do not simply drive.
They teleport.
They move through New Braunfels traffic the way legends move through stories — faster than expected, cooler than possible, and somehow still smiling. One of them handed me the boxes with the serene confidence of someone who knows he is delivering more than food. He is delivering joy. I tipped him like he had just personally improved the quality of my entire week.
Special, highly public, possibly career-defining shout-out to Manager Noah:
Noah.
You magnificent, sauce-stained sorcerer of happiness.
You run that kitchen like a benevolent wizard who has decided the only acceptable form of magic is making families feel seen and celebrated. Under your watch, ordinary pizza becomes folklore. Ordinary Tuesday nights become the kind of stories grandparents will tell while laughing and wiping happy tears. I don’t know what you put in the dough, but if it’s not pure Texas sunshine mixed with the purest intentions, I don’t want to know.
We live close enough that I can smell your ovens when the wind is right. We are regulars. We have the kind of relationship with this place that most people only dream of having with their favorite people. Mattenga’s doesn’t just feed us — it reminds us that in a world that sometimes feels rushed and impersonal, there still exist places where human beings look at each other and decide, “Tonight, we are going to make someone feel like royalty… with pizza rolls.”
This is not a review.
This is a love letter written in melted cheese.
This is me, a grown man, publicly admitting that if Mattenga’s ever closed I would stand outside with a handmade sign that simply says “This is where joy used to live” and refuse to leave until they came back.
Noah. Drivers. Entire crew.
You didn’t just deliver dinner.
You delivered a small, delicious, slightly outrageous piece of heaven to a regular family’s doorstep.
Five stars is an insult.
I’m giving you the entire night sky, a parade down Seguin Avenue, and my eternal loyalty.
Thank you for existing.
Thank you for the pizza rolls.
Thank you for making New Braunfels taste like the best version of home.
Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to go stare lovingly at the empty pizza boxes.🍕🔥❤️
— A man forever changed, slightly sticky, and completely yours