New York Pizza and Pints

Reviews

• LC

  Lauren Carlson

  2 days ago
  3.0
  Pizza was very good this time. Perfecty cooked. Tasted great. But, I did order and pay for pineapple on half of my pizza and there was no pineapple. I have ordered from them many times and it is hit or miss. When it's good it's really good. But other times it's overcooked. Or it's randomly closed. Somehow last time I ordered there was a glitch
• AF

  Adam Ferguson

  Apr 2, 2026
  5.0
  Possibly the best pizza I ever had. Fresh cut ingredients amazing crust.
• RH

  Random Havok

  Mar 26, 2026
  5.0
  unfortunately i can not rate anything but the service. we accidentally ordered from the wrong place but, when i called they were awesome about it, reversed the charges with no fuss. thank you and i will eat there if im in town 100%
• AW

  Am W

  Mar 25, 2026
  1.0
  I should have listened to the reviews. The pizza was dry and burnt. Calling this New York pizza is a tad disrespectful.
• TT

  Truth

  Mar 15, 2026
  2.0
  I'm a native New Yorker and I've ordered from New York Pizza and Pint Mckinney location quite a few times yearning for an authentic NY slice. There pizza is decent but, they don't put enough sauce. No one should have to order and pay for extra sauce because their pizza is lacking the appropriate amount. I usually order a pie. Today I ordered a Supreme Slicezilla on Door Dash at 12pm. Which is lunch hour and they sent me what appeared to be a day old (maybe even 2 days) slice of pizza. It was burnt and hard with a small sprinkle of fresh shredded mozzarella and fresh toppings over the old pizza. So gross! I threw it away and made a complaint to Door Dash for a refund.