Prince Street Pizza

Reviews

• JG

  John Gon

  2 days ago
  2.0
  I’m from NYC. I’m sorry this place is overrated. I’ve had better pizza at Yonx pizza in Wylie Tx . Their thin large pizza beats this pizza every time. No place for indoor dining. Love their large tree out doors. But that’s it…
• JG

  Joshua Galeas

  Jun 29, 2026
  5.0
  Prince street Pizza has amazing pizza with a variety of astonishing classical and new flavors. The employees give out an amazing service to everyone as well as being sure you get the decent experience needed here. The atmosphere is phenomenal with the patio sitting outside fitting for the afternoon or evening. 10/10.
• CT

  Chris Topher

  Jun 28, 2026
  1.0
  Im in disbelief three of us customers pizza got burn which is okay they were gonna remake them for us and thats okay. But to the two customers that were white got an apology and given tokens to try them again but me the hispanic person in his work shirt had to ask for the sauces i bought bc they didnt even acknowledge me or care. Im in disbelief and before anyone says its a race thing it maybe not that but to me at that moment it felt that way. I might be overreacting but it felt hurtful to be treated in that manner tbh.also i even got the wrong order, in this this box i didnt even had the meatlovers and it had different pizzas from what i picked in the window.
• FF

  Foodie.Luvers

  Jun 28, 2026
  1.0
  We were excited to try Prince Street Pizza since it originated in New York and is fairly new to Dallas. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to expectations. My friend is from New York and knows his pizza well, and he felt it was more like Chicago-style than authentic New York pizza. The highlight of our visit was Princess, who took our order. She was friendly, welcoming, and provided excellent customer service. On the other hand, the gentleman working in the back came across as rude and lacked basic customer service skills. Hoping the food and overall service improve over time. Hard Pass For New York Style Pizza highly recommend Fortunate Son in Garland
• CM

  Cameron McDonald

  Jun 11, 2026
  5.0
  As a big fan of the original Prince Street Pizza in NYC I was very excited to see this location open in Dallas. I did decide for the initial rush to die down a bit but I had to come give this spot a try. We stopped in and were greeted right away and the lady working the counter was very friendly and answered all of our questions. For Pizza we had the Naughty Pie, Fancy Prince, and Spicy Alfredo. The thick slices had a rich flavor to the crust and the toppings were outstanding. The thin crust is definitely among the best in Dallas and truly adds to the experience. I really feel like the pizza here stands up to the original and is super tasty. The patio outside with tables is a welcome addition if you have ever been to the original. Parking is an adventure so give yourself time to find some. Great spot! Highly Reccommended!