CD
Cynthia Dooley
May 2, 2026
My expectations of Pappadeaux were not terribly high. We hadn't been there in a few years and were not sure what we might see. I was afraid it might have turned to cheaper ingredients, or the dining room might show its age.
The menu has fewer choices and includes some new recipes, all of which sounded needlessly complicated to me. A great piece of fish doesn't need to be topped with a creamy sauce made with three types of shellfish.
We stuck to Pappadeaux tried-and-trues instead, and we had a great meal last night.
It wasn't a full house like it would have been on a Friday night back in the day, but many tables were filled, and the atmosphere was bustling. My spouse got a 16-oz ribeye, a huge, loaded baked potato and a big tangle of broccolini, all perfectly cooked, for $50. I ordered the seafood mixed grill skewers, a dish I have found irresistible for 25+ years now. It appears only on the lunch menu these days, but the kitchen made a dinner version at my request. It was just as great as I remembered: a huge portion of chunks of shrimp, salmon and sea scallops, grilled en brochette together with onions, bell pepper, zucchini and mushrooms, all served on a mountain of dirty rice, for $40.
For this quality and quantity of food, carefully and deliciously prepared, our $90 tab for two felt like a real value. It would have been double that amount at a high-end steakhouse.
Service was low-key and gracious, albeit harried. We were not offered bread service before our meal, but we didn't miss it.
We asked for a piece of their amazing praline cheesecake to take home. We were sad to hear they no longer offer it.
I still love that the place has a legit parking lot, so that I'm not forced to deal with the valets that have become ubiquitous in Uptown, Oak Lawn, Lower Greenville, etc.
Pappadeaux is aging well in this challenging, novelty-obsessed restaurant environment. We will return.