SO
Sherry Olson
Aug 3, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
46th Street Pizza is hands down my favorite pizza place. Even though I’ve never actually been inside the restaurant, we order takeout regularly, and it never disappoints. Every single order is consistently fresh, delicious, and made with care.
Our go-to is always the 46th Street Special. The combination of toppings is incredible, and the balance of sauce, cheese, toppings, and dough is absolutely perfect. The crust has just the right texture, the sauce is flavorful without overpowering the pizza, and the quality is top-notch every single time.
Today we tried the Chicken Alfredo Pizza, and wow—it was outstanding. The Meat Lovers Pizza is another favorite in our house and is always loaded with flavor.
And don’t sleep on the sandwiches! If you’ve never had one, you’re seriously missing out. My recommendations:
🥇 Italian
🥈 Philly Cheesesteak
🥉 Chicken Parmesan
I don’t know if they make their sandwich bread in-house, but it’s phenomenal. It somehow holds everything together without getting soggy, and the bread-to-meat-to-veggie ratio is perfect. Every bite is packed with flavor.
We’ve tried a lot of their menu over the years, and everything has been consistently amazing. That’s hard to find these days.
10/10. It hits every single time. If you’re looking for great pizza and incredible sandwiches, do yourself a favor and give 46th Street Pizza a try!