Tony C's Pizza & Beer Garden - Anderson Lane

Reviews

• MM

  Melody M

  6 days ago
  5.0
  I love getting the 2 slice and drink special here after work! They have the diner vibe and great customer service from Alexa in the front She always recommends great options and lets us know the pizza of the day!
• PS

  Paul Santiago

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Great visit! My bartender Kenneth was very attentive and recommended the pizza of the month to me. The pizza was actually incredible. I’ve been looking for true New York style pizza for a while. I’m glad to know there’s a local spot with it. Also, the manager Anna was so sweet and helpful. She stopped by and checked on me twice and made sure my visit went good. She told me to come back on the 14th for a free glass since I like the love street.
• DF

  Darius Fields

  May 8, 2026
  5.0
  Great food. Great atmosphere. Employees are very welcoming. Love coming here with my family. Absolutely love Bri. She has excellent customer service. Always attentive and puts a smile on my face every time. She's so amazing.
• MA

  Manuel Alday

  May 5, 2026
  4.0
  We arrived at about 3pm. The pizza was ok. The lasagna was amazing definitely a 9 out of 10. Service was outstanding. Pizza was a 6.3 out of 10. We also tried the calamari but it was not for us. 4.1 out of 10. Overall a good experience but wouldn't be excited to go back.
• DA

  Danielle Augustine

  Apr 18, 2026
  2.0
  Came here thinking we would beat a lunch rush just before noon and with the tables being mostly open and being wood fired pizza we also expected to be eating within 15/20 mins max. What we got was one small pizza delivered 40 mins after we started timing things and our second small pizza arrived almost 50 mins after we had ordered. We saw lots of take out pizzas being made and delivered to people stopping in and some of the other tables who came in after us also had their pizzas delivered before one of ours was ready so however the tickets were being handled was out of order and we saw another table waiting quite a while for a second pizza- and they did not appear happy either. As far as what we decided to try, my husband and l wanted the Little Italy with ricotta, capicola, basil and spicy honey. Pizza was very greasy and so overcooked in spots that it was crunchy all the way through, including the cheese itself. Ricotta was in puddles and was rather unpleasant for my husband. Our son's pepperoni and sun dried tomato pizza (that came out first) was actually good, but not worth 40 mins wait. Would not come back. Between the loud music, the wait time in a restaurant that was not even half full, the quality of the pizza and the stomach ache l got starting with the first slice- it would not be worth another attempt. The only positive l can report was that the young woman who took our order was exceptionally friendly and when l told her how long the order was taking (at the 35 min mark) she checked on things rt away and came back to assuring us we would have the pizza in 5 mins and we did get our son's pizza within 5/6 minutes. She looked a little stressed, like she was juggling alot- maybe managing? She was very responsive though and l did appreciate that.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tony C's Pizza & Beer Garden - Anderson Lane