KN
Katharine Nelson
Sep 26, 2026
Ordered some pizza on our vacation is it was delicious! I was super excited to get a gluten free pizza on our trip! And I loved that I could order a half and half pizza! I also had called to make sure my daughter could eat there, she’s dairy free, and the crust was dairy free! It wasn’t her favorite pizza but she still enjoyed it and at it all. Without cheese she wished for more pepperonis but that’s a personal problem not a restaurant problem!
BW
Bret Weaver
Sep 26, 2026
If you like good customer service, this is a spot to hit up.
We placed our order online and when we got there they had been having computer problems and had not received the order so we had no food. They apologized for the issue and comped us an app while we waited for the pizza to be made. Bonus, the pizza was absolutely delicious 🤤
So many places these days you would have just gotten a shrug and maybe a "sorry" but everyone we interacted with was genuinely apologetic and committed to making it right. Wow, great people and great food!
MF
Mara Frybarger
Sep 23, 2026
Long time fan of the Pizza Mill. The staff is always kind, the owners are great people, and the food never misses. Pizza, sandwiches, and wings are all fantastic here. I haven’t personally tried the pasta, but my son loves it!
SP
Shannon Morgan Peter
Sep 20, 2026
The pizza here is good, but it is a bit over priced in my opinion. And they have a medium and then extra large? Where is your large option. I spent $60 for a medium, chicken wings, which I won’t order again, and a side salad, which was just lettuce and a little bit of tomatoes and a sprinkle of cheese, won’t waste my money on that as well. I will just stick to a pizza if we order again from here.
BR
Bonnie Reimann
Sep 19, 2026
Excellent pizza and great service. Everyone was helpful and pleasant. I had the gluten free bbq chicken and it delicious and my husband had the meat lovers and enjoyed that too! Would recommend! Parking can be tough to find but we parked in the nearby grocery store way in the back.