Upper Crust Pizza & Wings

Reviews

• QM

  Quinn Millibergity

  1 day ago
  5.0
  The service was terrific. Very friendly and helpful staff. The pizza was delicious.
• GM

  george markopoulos

  Aug 2, 2026
  1.0
  Services were so BAD we watch 3 tables sit down after us and there food came out before us server didn’t put our order in how can you forget you table of 7 never going BACK !!!!
• EM

  Edward Morgan

  Jul 30, 2026
  4.0
  Excellent pizza, good beer selection. Prices were about average. Service was slow.
• CC

  Central Wisconsin Dog Sports Club

  Jul 22, 2026
  1.0
  We were on our first vacation in over 6 years and decided to stop this local pizza place. Pizza was good, wings were "meh" at best. Added salad bar to the meal only to find that it was mostly empty and they were not filling any more of the salad bar ingredients; was charged full price for the salad bar. What made it really awful was the service...or lack thereof. Waitress was non-existent. And, the place was not busy, either. The experience is something I will not forget anytime soon, and not for good reasons.
• MS

  Marya Sanders

  Jul 11, 2026
  2.0
  So excited to see 2 gluten free crust options. Ordered the gluten free and was served the cauliflower crust instead. The pizza was subpar and the waitress was not friendly. Did not come to check on us. Cauliflower crust was served and we never got our 1 large pizza or the wings and we waited over 30 minutes. Finally asked another waitress to check on our order as our waitress was not around. Watched our waitress get loud and rude with the other waitress who was simply trying to help. Eventually our waitress came back blamed the kitchen for skipping our order and we asked for the bill. She comped our wings which I'm assuming had been sitting waiting for a pizza that wasn't in the order que. She then proceeded to tell us she knew we were upset so she removed the portion of the bill allowing for a tip. Never once apologized or owned the mistakes. It is notable that the restaurant was mildly busy when we arrived but cleared out within 10 min of our arrival.