Malatesta's Italian American Pizza

Reviews

• KJ

  Kelly Joseph

  Oct 7, 2026
  5.0
  What can I say it was amazing … always is, i barely got thru the door and downed 3 slices so fast you woulda thought someone was trying to steal them from me. Washed it down with a crisp Diet Coke.
• MC

  Michael Collins

  Oct 3, 2026
  5.0
  Make sure that you order ahead, very busy. Food is delicious ! I had the pizza and cheese steak, excellent!! You can tell they use the best of ingredients!
• JK

  joseph kelly

  Sep 27, 2026
  5.0
  The Bar Pie is legendary! Today was my first order and it’s now my first call for great food! Joe Kelly
• SS

  SkI Szymanski

  Sep 23, 2026
  5.0
  We loved our pep and onions Pie! The Boys who own the pizza shop are really genuine! Their father's pictures, who were also pizza makers, are hung on the wall as you walk in! A great testament to the family history and love they have for their Dad's and the art of making great pizza!
• DD

  Denise

  Sep 10, 2026
  5.0
  Fantastic experience from pick up to empty pizza box. I got the original pizza with mushroom and black olives. It took everything in me not to eat a slice driving home. Most places I need to tell them to make it well done when I order it. Not here , it comes out perfect every time without adding my two cents of how it should be done. Delicious and consistent every time! ❤️ 🍕