CG
Carter Griffith
Sep 22, 2026
The BLT was huge and had so much bacon on it, while the bread was perfectly crisp, the fries hit the spot then my mother got the taco Tuesday special, which was so vibrant and amazing
Having dined at almost every spot around New Castle over the years, I can say without hesitation that Patsy’s Bar & Grill stands in a league of its own. While so many places rely on shortcut ingredients like canned tomato bases or pre-packaged foods, Patsy’s does things the authentic Italian way—scratch-made from start to finish with zero compromises. You can taste the genuine effort in every bite, from their rich, slow-cooked red sauce seasoned with real Italian expertise to their fresh ground meats, hand-breaded cuts, and house-made pasta. Even historic local staples simply don't match the standard they used to set half a century ago, but Patsy’s keeps the original culinary tradition alive.
Beyond the outstanding food, what truly sets Patsy’s apart is the passion and hospitality behind the counter and in the kitchen. Every dish reflects a dedication to real ingredients, hard work, and hearty portions served with genuine warmth. It’s rare to find a restaurant that still grinds, breads, preps, and cooks everything in-house with such pride. For locals and visitors alike who appreciate authentic, scratch-cooked Italian comfort food, Patsy’s is not just another option—it is the absolute gold standard for homemade dining in New Castle. I remember distinctly over half a century ago, Lee Troggio made homemade sauce and pasta.
RM
Rachelle Mansfield
Sep 21, 2026
Ordered a pickup dinner of chicken parm and build your own burger, and it was delicious. SO much food and quality ingredients. Tons of fries & My husband loved the meatballs as well. Will definitely be in with our extended family.
BF
betty jo felsing
Sep 19, 2026
Pizza was delicious! Properly prepared, lots of toppings! Sauce was delicious, will definitely be back!
JN
John Nicklin
Aug 16, 2026
Took 10 minutes for someone to wait on me and when I got there the pizza was sitting on a table when I asked about if it was cold they said they just brought it out. It was cold and soggy would not recommend the pizza