MYSTERY BEER
$2.00
"YOU GET WHAT YOU GET"
Business Details
540 E Fulton St, Lancaster, PA
17602, United States
Certified by Horse Inn • Jul 26, 2026
(717) 392-5528
Certified by Horse Inn • Jul 26, 2026
https://horseinnlancaster.com/
Certified by Horse Inn • Jul 26, 2026
About
Certified by Horse Inn • Jul 26, 2026
American RestaurantWine BarCocktail Lounge
Slightly off the beaten path, the Horse Inn restaurant has spent several generations striving to please its guests in Lancaster, PA. The main entrance was at one time on a narrow alleyway which, to this day, remains unnamed. In the early 1920s, the Shaub family renovated the second floor hayloft into a speakeasy. The original horse stalls were transported upstairs where wagon wheel chandeliers adorn the dining room.
The new owners of the Horse Inn, Matt and Starla Russell, have made several improvements to both the building and the menu. There are now two full bars and seating areas and a new, more accessible entrance on Fulton Street. Daily fresh ingredients and the use of local sources are crucial to Matt and Starla, who change the menu based on what is garden-fresh and in season. Don't worry; the infamous tenderloin tips on toast remain on the menu. The rich, brilliant dishes and one-of-a-kind cocktails will make you feel right at home.
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryNot available
- TakeoutAvailable
- Accepts reservationsAvailable
Location
Certified by Horse Inn • Jul 26, 2026
Hours
Certified by Horse Inn • Jul 26, 2026
MondayClosed
Tuesday5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Wednesday5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Thursday5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Friday5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Saturday5:00 PM - 11:00 PM
SundayClosed
Menu
4 menus · 128 items
Explore offerings from Horse Inn on 540 E Fulton St in Lancaster, with popular craft cans , domestic cans , appetizer, and salad available at this location.
BEER
28 items
CRAFT CANS
NEW BELGIUM FAT TIRE 16OZ
$6.00
AMBER ALE
SINGLECUT SOFTLY SPOKEN MAGIC SPELLS
$10.00
IPA
YARDS BRAWLER
$5.00
MILD
JACK'S HARD CIDER
$6.00
CIDER
PLOUGHMAN BIRDWATCHER
$9.00
CIDER
PLOUGHMAN STAYMAN WINESAP
$9.00
CIDER
NEW TRAIL BROKEN HEELS
$7.00
NEIPA
NEW TRAIL WHITE ALE
$7.00
WITBEIR
HALF ACRE GONE AWAY
$10.00
NEIPA
TWO LOCALS NUBIAN
$9.00
BROWN ALE
STILLWATER INSETTO
$8.00
SOUR
VON TRAP HELLES GOLDEN
$6.00
LAGER
VON TRAPP PILSNER
$6.00
PILS
VICTORY GOLDEN MONKEY
$7.00
TRIPEL
STILLWATER EXTRA DRY
$9.00
SAISON
HALF ACRE DAISY CUTTER
$9.00
SAISON
HALF ACRE PONY
$9.00
PILS
BURLINGTON VAULTED BLUE
$8.00
IPA
DOMESTIC CANS
MYSTERY BEER
$2.00
PBR
$2.00
NATTY BOH
$2.00
MILLER LITE
$3.00
COORS LITE
$3.00
BUD LITE
$3.00
YUENGLING LAGER
$3.00
BUDWEISER
$3.00
MICHELOB ULTRA
$3.00
FOOD
53 items
APPETIZER
PICKLES
$5.00
Rotating Selection of Pickled Vegetables
HORSE FRIES
$16.00
House Made Sausage, Parmesan and Aged Provolone Cheese, Garlic, Heavy Cream
1/2 HORSE FRIES
$8.00
WINGS
$17.00
1/2 WINGS
$8.50
BURRATA
$17.00
Caputo Brothers Hand Pulled Mozzarella, Housemade Ricotta, Local Tomatoes, Basil, Aged Balsamic Vinegar, EVOO, Focaccia Bruschetta
PA CHEESE BOARD
$19.00
Selection of Pennsylvania Cheeses, Served with Crackers and Foccacia, Honeycomb, and Housemade Jam
SQUASH BLOSSOMS
$10.00
SALAD
FARMERS SALAD
$13.00
Local Mixed Greens, Pickled Red Onion, Carrot, Radish, Tomato & Cucumber. Choice of House-made Dressing: Buttermilk Ranch, Blue Cheese or Honey Lemon Vinaigrette - GF, V (add 3.5oz tips +8, add 7oz tips +16, add chicken +9, add shrimp +9)
WEDGE SALAD
$14.00
Romaine Lettuce, Danish Blue Cheese, Cherry Pickled Red Onions, Bacon, Croutons, House Made Buttermilk Ranch
SIDE FARMERS
$6.50
SANDWICHES
HORSE INN CHEESEBURGER
$18.00
Custom Blend of Short Rib, Brisket, Chuck & 10% Dry Aged Beef, Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, White American Cheese, Special Sauce, Alfred & Sam's Bun (with fries +3)
HAMBURGER
$18.00
Horse Inn Burger Minus the Cheese (with fries +3)
BLT
$15.00
Housemade Bacon, Heirloom Tomatoes, Shredded Lettuce, Duke's Mayo, Texas Toast
ENTREES
TIPS N TOAST
$30.00
Tender Beef Tips, Alfred & Sam's French Bread, Red Wine Demi-Glace
SHRIMP & GRITS
$24.00
Shrimp, Marsh Hen Mill's Stoneground Grits, House Made Sausage, Peppers, Onions, Veal Stock {GF}
FRESH CATCH
$40.00
PUTTANESCA
$19.00
MUSSELS
$24.00
CHICKEN FRICASSEE
$24.00
SUMMER GRAIN BOWL
$18.00
DESSERTS
POT DE CREME
$6.00
Chocolate French Custard, Whipped Cream
SWEET CREAM
$4.00
CHOCOLATE
$4.00
SNICKER DOODLE
$5.00
CAKE CUTTING
$2.00
ORANGE CREAMSICLE
$5.00
BLUEBERRY
$5.00
LEMON BLUEBERRY CAKE
$12.00
WINE
24 items
DRINKS
23 items
COCKTAILS
COMEBACK KID
$15.00
Aged Rum, Amaro Nonino, Aperol, Lemon
COSMONAUT
$14.00
FOURTH REGIMENT
$15.00
FULTON STREET SOUR
$13.00
Old Forester Bourbon, Amaretto, Demerara Syrup, Lemon, Bitterman’s Tiki Bitters.
IRISH COFFEE
$13.00
Slane Irish Whiskey, Whipped Cream, Demerara, LCCR Coffee
LAUREL STREET
$14.00
MANHATTAN
$16.00
Templeton 4 Year Rye, Carpano Antica, Luxardo Maraschino, Angostura Bitters, Boker’s Bitters.
MYRTLE KOMBAT
$15.00
OLD FASHIONED
$14.00
Old Forester Bourbon, Brandied Cherry, Demerara Sugar, Angostura Bitters, Orange Zest.
PISTOL UNDER THE PILLOW
$14.00
Gin, Honey, Grapefruit, Lemon, Vanilla
SAVING GRACE
$13.00
Vodka, Lavender, Pomegranate, Orange, Lemon
SUITCASE
$16.00
THE GOSPEL
$14.00
THE OUTSIDER
$15.00
THE TUNNEL
$15.00
THUNDERBIRD
$16.00
WILD WHORSES
$15.00
HEAT LIGHTNING
$15.00
Frequently Asked Questions About Horse Inn
Does Horse Inn accept reservations and do I need to make one?
Horse Inn accepts reservations but they are not required. You can choose to book a table in advance or walk in.
What are the dining hours for Horse Inn?
The restaurant is open from Tuesday to Saturday, 5:00 PM to 11:00 PM. It is closed on Sundays and Mondays.
What are the kitchen hours at Horse Inn?
The kitchen is open Tuesday through Saturday from 5:00 PM to 9:30 PM. Horse Inn is closed on Sunday and Monday.
Does Horse Inn offer dinner and late-night meals?
Yes, Horse Inn serves dinner and late-night food.
What types of cuisine or specialties does Horse Inn offer?
Horse Inn specializes in Lancaster grown ingredients, crafted cocktails, and welcomes everyone to enjoy their menu.
What is the dress code at Horse Inn?
The dress code at Horse Inn is casual.
Does Horse Inn have a bar and what kind of drinks are offered?
Yes, Horse Inn has two full bars on site offering cocktails, beer, wine, and other alcoholic beverages.
What payment methods are accepted at Horse Inn?
Horse Inn accepts American Express, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa credit cards. Debit cards are also accepted, but cash only is not required.
Are there family-friendly amenities at Horse Inn?
Yes, Horse Inn welcomes families, has a children's menu, and provides high chairs.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Horse Inn?
Nearby you can visit Marshall Street Bookstore for a great local book selection or stop by My Shop Barbershop and Salon if you want a haircut. For those interested in arts, the Classical Guitar Society of Lancaster offers music events, and St. Anthony of Padua Church is nearby if you want to see historic religious architecture. Also, the Caribbean Wave Jamaican Jerk Restaurant is close if you're interested in more dining options.
Brand Certified Facts from Horse Inn
This information is certified by Horse Inn and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified July 26, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website