Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Reviews

• TS

  Too sweet Sweetie

  5 days ago
  4.0
  First time ordering from Valerio's, my super combo sub an pep balls were awesome. So I'll definitely be ordering again when back in town. 👌👍
• SS

  steffani Sorge

  Aug 12, 2026
  5.0
  I made an online order, it was busy as ever. Waited a few moments in line, the young gal asked me my name and number but almost was unable to know my order, find my order in the stacks of orders on counter. However, the food was so good nothing else matters. 😋 has never disappointed. Love your pep balls 💙
• PK

  paul karpinski

  Aug 8, 2026
  5.0
  We had never been to Valerio's. We live 2hrs South of Erie. We fall into the trap of always eating on Peach Street- "convenient." We were going to Erie to Celebrate our Daughter's Birthday! Let's try somewhere "New" to Us we thought! We did some research before we headed to Erie....And are we glad that we did!! Two of us had the ravioli/meatballs and my husband had their Italian sub!! We are looking forward to our next trip to Erie and the Yummy meal that we get at Valerio's!!
• TS

  Tim Shuhart (Squidlet62)

  Jul 13, 2026
  5.0
  Staff was great, very patient even though they were busy. Food was pretty good, home made noodles in the Seafood Supreme were just okay. Everything was seasoned just right.
• LB

  Lisa Burford

  Jul 8, 2026
  5.0
  The atmosphere is comfortable and quaint, and the service was wonderful! But the food was over the top! Fresh, authentic flavor, cooked to perfection! I ordered chicken parmesian and fettuccine Alfredo with a side salad. (BTW the rumors about the ranch are true!l) That ranch dressing was top notch !! The best !! The fettuccine noodles were al dente! Perfect! The sauce was so creamy (it was dreamy)! The chicken parmesian was also perfect, with the outer crunchy layer topped with home made sauce and cheese. The chicken was and tender and juicy and cooked well! Also I tried one meatball. Its everything I had hoped to experience and it was about 2 in diameter. It was very, very, good as well!! I couldn't believe how good the whole meal was and for about $20!! How reasonable are the prices! Thank you Valerio's! For a great meal, authentic, while away from home!