Mamma Lucrezia's Italian Restaurant

Reviews

• CS

  Chris Satterfield

  May 9, 2026
  5.0
  First time while in town for son’s graduation at Penn State. The food was absolutely fantastic! Highly recommended the chicken parm! Completely homemade. Should definitely try this place!
• JW

  Jonathan Witherspoon

  May 8, 2026
  5.0
  This town allows you to step back in time and this restaurant allows your taste buds to step into Sicily. I’ve had the good fortune to eat in Rome, Naples, Positano, Capri, New York City, and Chicago. I’ve never had a Chicken Marsala close to as good as Mamma Lucrezia’s.
• LS

  LIV SZULC

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  One of the best Strombolis I’ve ever had. 🔥👌🏼 Dough was the perfect bagel-like chewy, baked & seasoned to perfection. My fillings of choice — customized it with chicken, fresh tomato, basil/pesto, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, & parmesan — were added with a delicate touch, achieving a flawless balance of flavors. YUM, thanks chef! 🤤🫶🏻
• BG

  B. Gates

  Apr 19, 2026
  5.0
  If Momma Lucrezia's was located on Mulberry St in Manhattan it would be heralded in the NYT. The meals don't just get served here, they emerge from a kitchen you can tell is steeped in family, love and tradition. Every meal we've had there was excellent. If you like pretend Italian don't eat here. And I would suggest if you try Maria's cooking order a proper meal...you can get a decent pizza and sub at a lot of places...but not many places that advertise they are "Italian" restaurants produce meals as fantastic as Momma Lucrezia's. We've traveled 2 hours just to eat here. And yes, there are generations of Italians in the family.
• LR

  Liz Reed

  Apr 15, 2026
  3.0
  Wecordered through grubhub and understand prices are higher but I expect the same quality as what you supposedly serve in house! For $50, food only, we ordered #1)pepperoni sticks: barely any pepperoni or cheese--mostly pizza dough (bread). In fact, in the middle of each stick, there was nothing! So only a little pepperoni and cheese on the ends. WTH?!? #2)Caesar salad was good but small for the price! #3) Italian sub was Ok: not a lot of meat and cheese. Again, more bread than anything! Also, delivery time was delayed almost as soon as the order was placed, which it seems GH is now known for, for some reason. We probably will not order from this restaurant again 🙁