Tommy Boy's Pizza

Reviews

• AP

  Ashley Pecjak

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Best new favorite pizza spot!! Tried pizza for the second time and it was so good. Also got garlic knots and a salad. Everything tasted fresh and so flavorful! Can’t wait to go back again and try some new options!
• JV

  James Vernon

  6 days ago
  5.0
  I had this place in mentor so I was happy to see it came to Willoughby I live nearby. The pizza is amazing. We also tried a sub and the pepperoni roll and everything was great and the workers were friendly. Will be back this will become my go to pizza place!
• TD

  Terry Dybo

  Aug 5, 2026
  5.0
  The small is not really small, six big slices the crust was crunchy but not burned or dry, lots ( a whole lot) of cheese and sauce that was pleasantly on the sweet side. It was ready quick and the guys at the counter were very friendly especially considering the pizza was a free promo.
• KB

  Kevin Brown

  Aug 2, 2026
  2.0
  I ordered a pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was not very good, it was edible but that was about it, I ate it but didn't enjoy it. The garlic knots I'm not even sure had garlic on them, maybe a garlic butter but certainly not garlic. The garlic knots are also to large, you end up four large garlic knots over cooked on the outside with under cooked unseasoned dough on the inside ( roll the dough thinner and add six to an order with real garlic ). I tried Tommy Boys Pizza once and won't be back.
• AP

  Alex P

  Jul 29, 2026
  1.0
  I found out about the Kenny Lofton event and spent days getting ready. I went home to my parent’s house to find my childhood baseball cards and then drove around town to buy a Kenny Lofton card when I couldn’t find them. Got to the event about 2 hours early just so I could be towards the head of the line. After waiting for so long, we get to the counter and he tells us he’s not signing anything. I can’t tell you how disappointing that was. Man was my childhood baseball hero and couldn’t take 5 seconds to sign a card for a fan. Between that and the company’s use of AI in their fliers and website, I’ll definitely never be back. The pizza was just okay. That old motto “never meet your heroes” has never been more true than today.