Laurelville Pizza

Reviews

• LM

  Lauren McCree

  3 days ago
  5.0
  This little pizza place was wonderful! Im so glad we visited while we vacationed in Hocking Hills State Park area. The fried mushrooms were cooked to perfection, the pepperoni pizza was awesome and we loved the crust. We also finished our meal with some delicious icecream! The service we had from Mel was top notch. She was so friendly. It has that hometown diner feel where they know all the locals names when they walk in. I highly recommend stopping in if you're in the area! It was voted the best pizza place in Hocking County!
• RV

  Roy Vogtsberger

  3 days ago
  5.0
  After spending hours hiking in Hocking Hills, we stumbled across this little pizza joint. Boy are we glad we did! FANTASTIC pizza and calzone. Everything so fresh and delicious! If you are ever in this area, you will not go wrong eating at this place. Very reasonably priced and very generous sized items. Very friendly staff as well. The Vogtsberger family from Wichita Falls, Texas
• LM

  Lacey Moore

  4 days ago
  5.0
  I ordered take out, but it's definitely a cute little place I would take my kids. The food was excellent and portions are big. Ingredients were fresh and the staff was very friendly! Everyone who ordered loved their food, we had po boys, gyro, cheese curds and pretzel bites with beer cheese, everything was delicious! Will definitely visit again!
• KS

  Kaitlin Stapleton

  Jul 16, 2026
  5.0
  Me and my husband stumbled across this cute restaurant on our 2 hour drive home and it was delicious!!! The pricing was tremendous compared to scioto county OH ! We enjoyed pizza , mac and cheese bites and jalapeno poppers and got two FRESH HOT donuts 😍!! The waitress was sweet as can be and provided wonderful service and the owner was so nice he came out and spoke to me personally about our experience he truly cared about what we thought!! 10/10 can't wait to come back !!!
• SK

  Scott Kilburn

  Jun 28, 2026
  5.0
  My family spent the week in Hocking Hills and wanted pizza our last night there. I figured we'd find something to satisfy the craving, but with relatively mid expectations. I found Laurelville Pizza, with pretty rave reviews, and it was only 15 minutes from where we were staying - A little pizza place in a little town in the middle of nowhere with nearly 600 reviews and an average score of 4.8-stars. This place is deserving of all the 5-star reviews and positive comments given and really, the pizza I had goes on my list of all time favorites. I've had some good and fancy wood-fire oven pizzas before, most of which were amazing and this place can compete with those in taste (these are not cooked in a wood-fire oven). I'm not even sure I can pinpoint just one thing about it that makes it so good because everything from the crust, to the cheese, to the sauce was just so perfect. I'm really gushing over this place right now, but I could tell from the moment I picked up my order that it was going to be delicious. It just smelled good. And if not for the smell, this thing even looked amazing when I took a peek in my car. So awesome tasting pizza, but also my single experience with their service level was also good. I placed the order online with it telling me there would be a 35 minute wait. I showed up almost exactly 35 minutes later and there were just boxing everything up for me. *gush*