Columbus Fish Market

Reviews

• DB

  Dan Bell

  2 days ago
  3.0
  My family and I visited recently and it was ok. The food was the best part (I had the filet mignon and my wife and son had the lobster bisque and cod) - all very tasty. On the more negative side... seating is very cramped in the booths. My son and I (both over 5'10") kept accidentally kicking each other as there wasn't much in the way of leg room -- if you're on the taller-side, you may want to request a table. Food came out quickly but our server became argumentative when I mentioned a drink wasn't to my liking. It may be best to skip the mixed drinks here. Beer selection is also not particularly robust but my wife gave the wine she had a thumbs up.
• CC

  Chloe conley

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Service was fast and excellent. They have a great membership we signed up for. No catch just a great way to earn points at a place we love! Able to earn free things while enjoying really great food. Server was awesome had a great personality and was about to laugh and get some of the best dishes on the menu! Recommend the stuffed salmon which is prepared daily by the chef! Who stepped to our table to make sure the food came out properly and to our liking. Easy parking and great music!!! Staff was friendly and they have a great deal on Tuesday’s for lobster tails not to mention weekly they have a 36$ meal for one. I got the lobster bisque and stuffed salmon my husband got the deader salad and lobster tails. Everything was beyond wonderful. If you’re looking for a great dinner with attentive and friendly staff this is the place to be and go!
• CC

  Chloe Conley

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Went for happy hour in the bar and it was outstanding! Everything came out hot and fresh! The bartenders were so friendly and helpful guiding us to the perfect cocktails! The host upfront was so kind and warm when we came in really made the atmosphere welcoming and a great balance and energy in the air. They also have take home fresh fish. The chef was awesome even came to our table to ask us how everything was. Top notch service. 10/10
• TH

  Teka H

  Aug 1, 2026
  1.0
  Review: My friends and I visited Fish Market on Saturday, August 1st, around 3:00 p.m. We were looking forward to enjoying happy hour and spending time together, but unfortunately, our experience was very disappointing. From the moment we arrived, the service felt unwelcoming. We waited approximately 15 minutes before receiving water or menus. When the menus were finally brought out, they were all placed in front of those of us seated at the bar, even though the rest of our group was seated at a nearby table. When someone from our party asked where their menus were, the server simply pointed and said, "They're right there," without making any effort to hand them to the guests. It came across as cold and dismissive. After we placed our food order, we were informed that the restaurant only had one order of chicken wings remaining. It was surprising to learn this only after ordering, especially for such a common menu item. Running out of staple items during service reflects a lack of preparation and inventory management. What stood out most was the overall lack of hospitality. Throughout our visit, no manager stopped by to check on our table or address our experience. Although a different server from the first rude one was the only person who interacted with us, the overall atmosphere made us feel like our business wasn't valued. Considering the restaurant was not busy at the time, we expected a much higher level of attentiveness and customer service. I don't typically leave negative reviews, but this experience fell well below expectations. I hope management takes this feedback as an opportunity to improve both customer service and operational planning. Unfortunately, based on this visit, I don't plan to return.
• DS

  D S

  Jul 28, 2026
  5.0
  This was my first time here, I loved the food. I got the broiled seafood platter with a crab cake, a mixed drink, and cheesecake for dessert. It was an excellent dinner. The presentation was very good, nothing over the top. The portions were perfect. The scallops, crab cake, and mashed potatoes were the highlight of the meal. I really enjoyed it overall. The shrimp was slightly overcooked but it was good. The food was ready quite quickly and it was piping hot, very happy with the kitchen. Nothing was wrong. My waiter was Justin tonight. Please send him my regards. Thank you for a great birthday dinner. I wasn't having a good day and I was kinda sad to have dinner alone. But he was helpful and welcoming. I appreciate that he listened to what I was asking and gave clear suggestions and info on the menu. And I really appreciate the ice cream and candle, that was a nice touch. He strongly contributed to making the experience great for me and I appreciate his professionalism. He was attentive and respectful. The only thing I would say I disliked from the experience was the arrangement of tables. I was hoping there would be a more private booth somewhere. I was also hoping that the atmosphere would be a bit more upscale. It was definitely a grade above casual, but the interior was underwhelming in the style and arrangement. It still felt too casual for the menu and reputation. The dining area is smaller than expected and it felt cramped. Cheaper than Ocean Club, only slightly lower quality food preparation. Definitely worth a visit if you don't want to spend $200 per person at Ocean Club.

Frequently Asked Questions About Columbus Fish Market