Sandwiches made with hand-sliced meats, fresh veggies and bread that's never more than 4 hours old. Freaky Fast® makes it Freaky Fresh.® Order online for delivery or pick up.
Explore offerings from Jimmy John's on 2497 E Main St in Bexley, with popular $5.99 sandwich deal, what’s new, toasted sandwiches, and wraps available at this location.
Menu
195 items
$5.99 Sandwich Deal
For a limited time, get a Turkey Tom®, The Pepe®, Vito®, or The Veggie for $5.99
Single protein and/or provolone served on 8" or 16" French, sliced wheat or Unwich®. Perfect for kids!
Slim 1
HAM & PROVOLONE
Slim 2
ROAST BEEF
Slim 3
TUNA SALAD
Slim 4
TURKEY
Slim 5
SALAMI, CAPOCOLLO & PROVOLONE
Slim 6
PROVOLONE
Desserts
Satisfy your sweet tooth with one of our cookies or brownie
PB&J Cookie
$2.35
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.35
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$2.35
Fudge Chocolate Brownie
$2.35
Sides
Add your favorite chips, pasta salad, or Jimmy Pickle
Buffalo Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
A crisp, refreshing mix of cucumbers, tzatziki, sliced pickles and onions for bright Greek flavor in every bite
BBQ Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
Jalapeño Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
Regular Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
Salt & Vinegar Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
Homestyle Potato Salad
$2.49
Pesto Bowtie Pasta Salad
$2.49
Bow tie pasta with creamy pesto dressing and sundried tomatoes.
Pickle (Whole)
$1.99
Pickle (Halved)
$1.99
Pickle (Quartered)
$1.99
Cucumbers (Sliced)
$0.99
French Bread
$2.99
Our Freaky Fresh® 16” French bread is perfectly golden and baked all day long. Quantity limitations and participation may vary by store.
Avocado Spread (Side Portion)
$1.49
Kickin' Ranch® (Small)
$0.75
Kickin’ Ranch® (Large)
$2.25
Creamy and cool ranch, with a kick of heat
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
$0.75
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
Homestyle Ranch (Large)
$2.49
Drinks
Choose from an assortment of fountain or bottle drinks
Regular Classic Lemonade
$2.49
Large Classic Lemonade
$2.99
Regular Strawberry Lemonade
$2.49
Large Strawberry Lemonade
$2.99
Bottled Water
$2.49
20oz Bottle Coke®
$2.79
Large Fountain Coke®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Coke®
$2.49
20oz Bottle Diet Coke®
$2.79
Large Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.49
Regular Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.49
Large Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.99
20oz Bottle Sprite®
$2.79
Large Fountain Sprite®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Sprite®
$2.49
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.99
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.49
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.99
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.49
Large Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.49
Large Fountain Root Beer
$2.99
Regular Fountain Root Beer
$2.49
Large Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.99
Regular Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.49
Large Fountain Hi-C® - Fruit Punch
$2.99
Regular Fountain Hi-C® - Fruit Punch
$2.49
Catering Bundles
Create the catering bundle of your dreams and get your favorite sandwiches, wraps, or both! Customize your sides, add desserts, and you’ve got yourself a perfect spread.
Small Catering Bundle
$89.99
Perfect for your next group occasion. This bundle feeds 6 to 10 and includes: 1 box of 18 third sandwiches, 6-pack individual premium sides, 6 chips, and 6 desserts.
Large Catering Bundle
$199.99
Perfect for your next group occasion. This bundle feeds 15 to 20 and includes: 1 box of 30 third sandwiches, 1 12-piece half wraps box, 2 6-pack individual premium sides, 15 chips and 15 desserts.
Chips Bundle
$9.99
Perfect for your next group occasion! This bundle includes a variety of 6 chips.
Desserts Bundle
$13.99
Perfect for your next group occasion! This bundle includes a variety of 6 desserts.
Bottle Drink Bundle
$10.49
Perfect for your next group occasion! This bundle includes a variety of 4 bottle drinks.
Party Boxes
Turn any gathering into a party with a box of delicious sandwiches or wraps. Choose from 12, 18, or 30-piece options.
18-Piece
$49.99
Box of 18 third sandwiches. Your choice of any of our sandwiches. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
30-Piece
$74.99
Box of 30 third sandwiches. Your choice of any of our sandwiches. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
12 Half Sandwiches
$49.99
Box of 12 half sandwiches. Your choice of any of our sandwiches. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
12 Half Wraps
$59.99
Box of 12 half wraps. Your choice of any of our wraps.
Box Lunches
Cover all your food bases with our box lunches. Comes with your choice of any regular sandwich or wrap, plus your choice of side, dessert, and pickle. What more could you need?
Box Lunches
$0.50 - $16.99
Box of your choice of sandwich or wrap plus a bag of chips, dessert & pickle spear. Some sandwiches cost a little more than others.
Lil' Lunches
$7.99
Box of your choice of a Little John & a bag of chips.
Desserts
Satisfy your sweet tooth with one of our cookies or brownie.
PB&J Cookie
$2.35
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.35
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$2.35
Variety Cookie
$2.35
Fudge Chocolate Brownie
$2.35
Brownie made with semi-sweet chocolate, cocoa and melted chocolate.
Sides
Add on chips, pickles, or new premium sides to your catering order.
Buffalo Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
A crisp, refreshing mix of cucumbers, tzatziki, sliced pickles and onions for bright Greek flavor in every bite
Pesto Bowtie Pasta Salad (Individual)
$2.49
Bow tie pasta with creamy pesto dressing and sundried tomatoes.
Homestyle Potato Salad (Individual)
$2.49
Regular Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
BBQ Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
Jalapeño Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
Salt & Vinegar Jimmy Chips®
$1.99
Pickle (Whole)
$1.99
Pickle (Halved)
$1.99
Pickle (Quartered)
$1.99
Pickle Bucket
$6.99
Cucumbers (Sliced)
$0.99
French Bread
$2.99
Our Freaky Fresh® 16” French bread is perfectly golden and baked all day long. Quantity limitations and participation may vary by store.
Avocado Spread (Side Portion)
$1.49
Kickin' Ranch® (Small)
$0.75
Kickin’ Ranch® (Large)
$2.25
Creamy and cool ranch, with a kick of heat
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
$0.75
Homestyle Ranch (Small)
Homestyle Ranch (Large)
$2.49
Drinks
Choose from an assortment of fountain or bottle drinks.
Bottled Water
$2.49
20oz Bottle Coke®
$2.79
Large Fountain Coke®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Coke®
$2.49
20oz Bottle Diet Coke®
$2.79
Large Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Diet Coke®
$2.49
20oz Bottle Sprite®
$2.79
Large Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Dr Pepper®
$2.49
Large Fountain Sprite®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Sprite®
$2.49
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.99
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Unsweet
$2.49
Unsweet Tea (Gallon)
$5.99
Large Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.99
Regular Fountain Iced Tea - Sweet
$2.49
Sweet Tea (Gallon)
$5.99
Large Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.99
Regular Fountain Cherry Coke®
$2.49
Large Fountain Root Beer
$2.99
Regular Fountain Root Beer
$2.49
Large Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.99
Regular Fountain Powerade® - Mountain Blast
$2.49
Large Fountain Hi-C® - Fruit Punch
$2.99
Regular Fountain Hi-C® - Fuit Punch
$2.49
Regular Classic Lemonade
$2.49
Large Classic Lemonade
$2.99
Regular Strawberry Lemonade
$2.49
Large Strawberry Lemonade
$2.99
Reviews
3.9
220 reviews
5 stars
120
4 stars
36
3 stars
22
2 stars
5
1 star
37
AJ
Avery Jehn
4 days ago
1.0
Me and a group of my friends came in at 730ish on October the 11th. We ordered, sat down, ate our food and as we were getting ready to leave a female worker was doing prep (slicing salami). We saw her pick up her phone and go on it for a second, take a drink of something, and also pouring candy in her hand (with the same gloves on!!) and she proceeded to put the candy in her mouth and her lips touched the gloves, then she went back to prepping with the same gloves on!! How disgusting.. we will not be back.
BM
Brian Miller
Sep 16, 2026
2.0
Was a loyal customer until the store would not issue a credit for missing items.
"Store policy" is, admittedly by their manager "we will not issue a credit no matter what happens on our end".
Ordered delivery thru their app. Some of the food was missing. I called in and the manager refused to re-deliver the missing items or issue a credit. Only offered a store credit. This is pure theft.
He went on and on that he cannot under any circumstances issue a refund for any reason. Absolutely ridiculous. Will be disputing partial payment with chase on principal. You cannot charge for something you forgot to deliver, refuse to redeliver and not offer money back.
TH
Truman Haycock
Jun 18, 2018
3.0
When I had questions about whether I was in/out of the store’s delivery range in Bexley, the same employee hung up on me twice, raised his voice, refused to let me speak to the manager, refused to give me his name, threatened me, and more. I’ve worked in the service industry for years and have never seen such poor performance.
UPDATE: The store owner and General Manager both spoke with me about the situation, apologized, and assured me that proper correctional measures are being taken. I trust them to do the right thing.
This information is certified by Jimmy John's and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified October 11, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: