F. Ottomanelli Burgers and Belgian Fries

Reviews

• HT

  Hạnh Trần

  3 days ago
  5.0
  As a traveller, I was recommend to try this place. I was surprised and amazed by the food, 10 out of 10 for. And the waiter & waitress here they’re both very friendly. If you are looking for a good steak house, definitely try here, and the owner is kind too. Perfect, love itttt
• MM

  Matthew McDermott

  3 days ago
  5.0
  I grew up on Long Island, and this is like an incarnation of all of the places I miss from childhood and teenage years. Delicious, affordable steak, fries, and a great atmosphere and service from the staff. Couldn't recommend this place enough.
• VS

  Victoria Siek

  May 12, 2026
  1.0
  Let me start off by saying that this review is not a reflection of the girl working the counter; she was incredibly sweet and really cared about the customers. However, Ottomanelli has turned from being the best burgers I’ve had to apparently the worst. I have been a regular for years. I was even here 2 weeks ago and it was great. I don’t know what happened in the span of those two weeks but the burger was absolutely terrible. The meat was thick, dry, and bland (not to mention 2 out of 4 of us asked for medium and we all got well done), the bun was completely different than usual (stale and cold; I don’t know if it’s from a different bakery but it’s sure tasted like it), the cheese was cold and not melted at all, there was almost no sauce, and overall it was just a terrible, tasteless experience. This is NOT the Ottomanelli that I know. Whoever was cooking the burgers (May 12 at 5:30pm) either needs more training or needs to find a different field to work in because this was just ridiculous. My family was visiting me from Poland and instead of showing them the best burgers in the world, they ate something worse than McDonald’s. The biggest disappointment is when you have high expectations and think you know what you’re getting and are left regretting that you even came. I really do hope this reaches the owner/manager because I hate to lose a place that I’ve been going to my whole life. So please, stop the new nonsense and go back to the real thing
• JR

  John Rummo

  May 2, 2026
  5.0
  Amazing burgers, staff is super nice