Miceli Brothers Pizza

Reviews

• HB

  Hannibal Bahnken

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Great little pizza place! If you like Calamari then this place is for you! Everyone is friendly, the prices are wallet friendly and everything we have tried is fantastic! You really should try the place!
• JC

  Jose Conde

  6 days ago
  5.0
  These guys are awesome. Made me a custom slice that's great.
• JT

  j t

  Aug 5, 2026
  3.0
  I tried a regular slice a Sicilian and a grandma slice. They seem to be lacking flavor. They were at best o.k. Disappointed won’t be coming back. Sorry.
• JS

  Joseph Sullivan

  Aug 5, 2026
  5.0
  Just outstanding pizza. Frank and his son Matt make great pizza s. All different types. Fresh mozz is great. Grandma great! They have lot of other delicious things like meat ball hero and chicken parm. I went to New Haven pizza places after hearing how good they are and I couldn’t wait to get back to Miceli bros for real pizza.
• QM

  Quintin May

  Jul 28, 2026
  1.0
  7/28/26 Order my 2nd pizza here, because the first one was mid. Got meatball this time, how can you mess it up. Undercarriage was good, sauce was lacking the taste of the Italy, guy behind the register sure did pretend to speak it tho. And the worst part was the cheese like I’m chewing a rubberized kids bop meal. Also got garlic knots, guess what, stale and hard as a rock. Notice the garlic burned to a crisp on the bottom of this knot. As someone who spent 3 week in Italy, works with wannabe Italian coworkers, and worked at a pizzeria where no one even pretended to speak Italian. This place is trash, go spend the extra $5 and go to Cafe Gio. I feel bad saying all this but I rather save the next guy a night of disappointment.