McGill's Whiskey Tavern and Grill

Reviews

• RK

  rick kilmer

  2 days ago
  2.0
  Visited after leaving Little Falls cheese fest. I ordered Chicken righties and traditional greens. Wife ordered meatball riggies. Server was nice friendly and prompt. Food was terrible. Portions were huge but on both half the pasta was stone cold and half was warm. Very few pieces of pasta was hot. Had to have been microwaved instead of cooked. The Greens were not edible. Overcooked till they were brown and mushy, not green like greens should be. Tasted of burned oil. Just horrible. Had to pay a little under $20 for them because the owner wasn’t there so the waitress couldn’t remove them from the bill. They serve inedible food and then make you pay for it I and I assume still want a tip. Will never ever return. I recomend to all stay away. Food sucks.
• MS

  Mike Shue

  Sep 26, 2026
  5.0
  Chicken bacon ranch Mac & cheese, lobster Mac & cheese and honey garlic, dill pickle and lemon pepper wings!!! Service was great, atmosphere was great and food was soooooo good! The portion sizes are HUGE!!!!!!
• KP

  Kylie Pratt

  Sep 21, 2026
  1.0
  My friend and I shared a chicken caesar salad today and now have food poisoning. I have had the worst stomach pains and BM for the last several hours 😭
• CC

  Colleen

  Sep 20, 2026
  5.0
  Excellent food, great service, very clean. Reasonable pricing.
• JL

  Jake Laribee

  Aug 8, 2026
  5.0
  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ **Holy shit. These chicken riggies.** I came to McGill’s Whiskey Tavern & Grill expecting a good meal. I did NOT expect to have a religious experience over a plate of pasta. These were hands down the **best chicken riggies I’ve ever had in my life**. The sauce was ridiculously creamy, insanely flavorful, and somehow I kept convincing myself that the next bite was going to be the one where I’d had enough. It never happened. And those hot cherry peppers?! 🔥 Absolutely PERFECT. That little kick cut through the creamy sauce and made every bite better than the last. I’m honestly a little upset that I’ve eaten chicken riggies anywhere else before this. If you’re anywhere near Utica and you’re debating what to order, stop debating. **Get the damn riggies.** You’re welcome.