Milton Point Provisions

Reviews

• VM

  Valeri Makovik

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Milton Point Provisions is a gem in Rye — great atmosphere, friendly staff, and consistently fresh, high-quality food. Perfect neighborhood spot for coffee, sandwiches, and quick gourmet bites.
• JB

  Jeffrey Berman

  5 days ago
  5.0
  I took a good friend out to dinner and decided to return to Milton Pt. Provisions. We had gone there for lunch after doing a hike with friends around Rye Playland. So worth the ten min drive! First off… lunch was awesome. Had their coffee and that alone would make me a regular if I was in the neighborhood. It’s not a big place so you may want to use whatever service locks in reservations. Anyway… I was touting to my friend how much I enjoyed Milton Point Provisions so we decided to go last night to catch up at a quiet place. Well we overloaded and brought home a lot of left overs. Well figured we could as I wanted him to try everything my eye caught & since they do takeout as well — why not? The hanger steak and ribs are delicious as was the salmon. We spoke to the owner (hey Monty!) and he explained how he has one of the few cooking smokers in the area. It really made the food super tasty and moist! Side dishes are yummy. In particular, The Brussels Sprouts (which I usually find too dry) were great. The appetizers were equally fantastic. You have to try the wings! Some of the best in Westchester! The sauces were perfect and the size of the wings themselves are big and not fatty. We didn’t have dessert as we were too full and were bringing home food but if you want to go to a not so fancy, super friendly, fair priced, great quality, low key place… then this will be your next “go-to”! Which is what you should do!
• DR

  Dorn Redd

  May 13, 2026
  5.0
  Absolute home run lunch! Phenomenal turkey sandwich (I'm a tough grader on turkey sandwiches) and the cauliflower appetizer was terrific! Service was great. And a great all around vibe!
• MC

  marian clarke

  May 8, 2026
  5.0
  Casual and friendly atmosphere. We were welcomed upon entering and service was attentive, but not over done. Breakfast offerings hit the spot. The owner stopped by our table and gave us a bit of history
• KH

  Kirk Holmes

  May 3, 2026
  5.0
  I had an amazing experience at Milton Point Provisions. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere feels welcoming and laid-back while still being polished. The space has a great local vibe that makes it perfect whether you’re grabbing a casual bite or meeting friends. The food was outstanding—everything tasted fresh, well-prepared, and thoughtfully put together. You can tell there’s real attention to quality and detail in every dish. The menu has a great variety, so there’s something for everyone, and it’s hard to go wrong with anything you order. Service was just as impressive. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything ran smoothly without ever feeling rushed. Overall, this is one of those spots you’ll want to keep coming back to. Highly recommend checking it out if you’re in the area