I started with a Philly cheesesteak. I’m sorry, but I don’t know what all the hype is about because it was average at best. I have to be honest that although it looked super delicious the bread was a little flavorless and for the way social posts had me hyped on how much you got versus what I received, it wasn’t worth it. I kept it simple by getting one regular slice and one of their Sicilians. Again, nothing special with the regular slice as the sauce was a little on the sweet side, but overall it was OK. The Sicilian was complete trash. Way too thick, way to doughy and lacked taste. I was really hoping that the hype was gonna live up to it, but it totally did not. I know there are people that love it, but it did not score any major points with me.
HB
Hecker Beluga
4 days ago
absolutely amazing once in a life time experience, the food is a bang for your buck financially and it melts in your mouth and it’s an explosion of flavor, if your stopping by the bayside this is definitely a to go
twaambo was amazing and hooked us up on the house with some slices alongside the food, give this man a raise alongside the other chefs💯💯💯💯
Amazing place! Thanks to Twaambo, I had not only a great conversation but also an excellent recommendation as a first-time customer at Krave-it.
The pizza was surprisingly really good. I say surprising because many other places I've tried with loaded topping pizzas weren't as good. But here, I kept going back for another bite after another—I wanted to savor each topping and see how they worked together.
Don't just order pizza from UberEats or DoorDash. Come in and see the slices yourself. Some of the pies are a bit more loaded and will fill you up quickly, while others are more balanced and aren't much different from a regular pepperoni slice. You should see it with your own eyes.
I also tried the Krave-it Bomber sandwich. Great flavor, though the size was good but not great. I would have loved it to be a bit longer… (pause… lol). But overall, very flavorful.
There will definitely be a next time. I want to try a few more pizzas and the homemade ice cream.
BR
Brook-Lynn Reign
Aug 8, 2026
I’ve ordered from here before and had a really good experience, so I was especially disappointed with this order. The first time I ordered The Sergeant pizza, it was delicious and I had no complaints.
This time, I ordered a cheese pizza and requested extra marinara sauce on the side for dipping. Unfortunately, my server, appears to have misunderstood the instructions and the pizza arrived with no marinara sauce on it at all just cheese and crust.
By the time it arrived, the pizza was close to room temperature, and the crust was extremely hard and dry. The small container of marinara that came on the side would have been perfect for dipping if the pizza had been made with sauce, but instead I had to use it just to make the pizza edible. I ran out of marinara halfway through the small pizza and couldn’t finish the rest, so most of the pizza ended up being a waste.
The fried Oreos were also disappointing. They were mostly thick dough, had very little Oreo flavor, and did not have any powdered sugar not even a light dusting. There was also no dipping sauce included.
I know this restaurant can do much better because I’ve had a good experience here before. I would probably order again, but next time I would pick it up myself so I can make sure the order is correct and the food is fresh and hot.
AR
Amanda Ramcharan
Aug 6, 2026
Krave It Sandwich Shop in Bayside is seriously one of the best spots around if you’re looking for something different. Their menu is packed with creative pizza slices you won’t find just anywhere, and every one looks better than the last. I tried the birria pizza slice and said it was so bomb crispy crust, flavorful, tender birria, melty cheese. So GOOD.
The staff is friendly, the food is fresh, and the whole place has a great vibe. If you’re in Bayside and want amazing sandwiches or unique pizza slices that actually live up to the hype, Leave It Sandwich Shop is a must-try. We can’t wait to come back and work our way through the rest of the menu!