BM
Brittany Martin
4 days ago
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Absolutely amazing! I tried Three Olives for the first time tonight, and I can officially say I found my new Mediterranean spot in the Hudson Valley!
The food was incredibly fresh and authentic. It honestly reminded me of the food I had while traveling in Egypt, which is not something I say lightly!
We tried the falafel platter with the house salad and the gyro with french fries, and everything was fantastic. Hands down some of the best Mediterranean food I’ve had in the area. The portions were generous, the prices were very reasonable, and the quality was excellent.
I’ve tried several other Mediterranean places around here and haven’t found one I’ve really loved—until now. Three Olives absolutely won me over! I will definitely be back very soon to dine in (this order was pick-up).
DL
D Lymberatos
Aug 2, 2026
I feel bad giving this place 2 stars because there were definitely some positives. Our waitress was excellent—she was very knowledgeable about the menu, explained the different flavors well, and provided great service throughout our visit.
The main reason for my rating is the menu. Many items listed weren’t actually available, and even after ordering, we were told that some dishes were unavailable. It was frustrating not having an updated menu and having to change our order multiple times.
I ordered the lamb platter, and while some of the meat was good, several pieces were small, tough, and difficult to eat.
That said, the restaurant offers some unique and interesting flavors, and I’d be willing to give it another try in the future. I hope they update their menu to reflect what’s actually available because I think the experience has the potential to be much better.
MH
Michael Harden
Aug 2, 2026
I tried a few menu items and everything was delicious and very flavorful. I will definitely eat here again
A total gem! Best mixed appetizer dips. Hummus, baba, and tziki can’t be beat. Great lentil soup and Greek salad. Fresh baked pita and everything made and served with skill and love. I hope it fries and they open more locations. I want to eat this food every day! Seriously!
DM
David Medina
Jul 28, 2026
Had the white rice with chicken and shrimp, super flavorful 10/10 then chocolate lava cake for dessert 10/10. First time coming here but definitely going to return again, overall excellent experience