La Roma Pastry Shop

Reviews

• BS

  Barbie S

  5 days ago
  5.0
  This is one of the best authentic Italian bakeries I have been to. The rainbow cheesecake, pastries, bread are all fresh and magnificent. Absolutely delicious. A must go to for all your bakery needs.
• MR

  Michele Russo

  May 11, 2026
  5.0
  I’ve been coming to this bakery for a while, and it never disappoints. Their custom made cakes have been a hit at every occasion I have celebrated at home, and their pastries are second to none. Their attention to detail makes it stand out compared to many other bakeries I have visited in the past. The customer service is also unmatched, especially Mariella. She always greets you with a smile, making you feel welcomed, and is genuinely kind and helpful, no matter how busy things are. You can tell she really cares about the customers, which is extremely rare to find. She helps foster an authentic and pleasant experience in this beautiful Italian bakery.
• CC

  Calogero C. Costantino

  May 8, 2026
  5.0
  Best cannoli cream I've ever had other than being in Sicily it's the best in New York without a shadow of a doubt the place is incredible
• CM

  Carly Mommy

  May 8, 2026
  5.0
  Beautiful inside and out I could smell it from the parking lot, and I HAD to see what the amazing smell was. Well, this bakery has outdone themselves it is beautiful, the staff are wonderful, and I wanted to just stay and relax there. The atmosphere is so chill and calm, it smells amazing and tastes even better. We loved our trip there and will be back again soon for more rainbow cookie cheesecake and Lindser tart!! Yum!!!!
• MP

  Maryann Peo

  May 3, 2026
  5.0
  Everytime we are down on the Island-- This is a Must!! All is made in house!! Bread,pastry, and the Gelato!! Forgettaboudda-it!! If available-- The Pistachio filled Crossaint!! You will NOT be disappointed!!

Frequently Asked Questions About La Roma Pastry Shop