The Pizza Box NY

Reviews

• CJ

  Charles Jenness

  2 days ago
  5.0
  We wandered into the the pizza box and were not planning on staying. Melanie intercepted us and "guilted" us into staying. We did not regret. Melanie and everyone who works at the Pizza Box could not have been nicer hosts. They checked on us constantly to make sure we had everything we needed. We liked it so much we came back the next day. I cannot recommend this place enough. On top of the great service the pizza is also AMAZING! There aren't enough stars to give this wonderful restaurant!
• AB

  Ari Belanger

  May 6, 2026
  5.0
  Absolutely wonderful, DELICIOUS pizza. This is definitely the place to get a proper new york pizza and natalie and gabby were so wonderful. Great atmosphere, hot pizza, good music, fun staff, great drinks. Visit this place. They just opened and they are worth it even if ur all the way up in harlem.
• FF

  Fabawan

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  J'adore cet endroit !! L'accueil est hyper chaleureux et les serveuses sont trop des amours (En plus il y en a une qui parle super bien Français) La salle est agréable et lumineuse avec vue sur le patio extérieur. Les prix sont tout à fait correct et biensûr le principal : Les pizzas déchirent tout !! Un regal !! Franchement une des meilleures pizzerias que j'ai pu testé sur Manhattan !
• CB

  Christina Bruni

  Apr 26, 2026
  5.0
  The Pizza Box is the perfect spot to host an event. They made my birthday so incredibly special both through how sweet and thoughtful the owner and staff were but also with how high quality all of the food and ingredients were. Thank you so much to Melanie, Michael, and the rest of the team for taking such great care of us and making our night so incredible. And also a special shoutout to Jayce, an absolutely phenomenal singer and made the night even more memorable. Cannot wait to go back and bring my family!
• BM

  Brian Martens

  Apr 24, 2026
  5.0
  Visited this wonderful restaurant on Bleeker Street the other night. Pizza can be ordered to go, but there is also seating in the back, and an additional outdoor space. The restaurant interior was cozy and clean with a ongoing theme of horses and barns. I found out the owners had started out by selling pizza out of a refurbished horse carriage in upstate NY. A portion of the carriage is featured in the outdoor area. We got 2 pizzas, the pepperoni honey and the pickled pizza. The honey matched great with the pepperoni, despite me being a bit unsure of this mix. I am a fan of food with some heat and the Pickled Pizza did not discourage. Jalapenos and hot honey were the perfect mix to satisfy my "heat" tooth. The owner provided us details on all the locally sourced ingredients that go into the pizza and you can definitely taste the difference. Looking forward to visiting this place again.