Pizza Collective

Reviews

• GC

  Glenn C

  1 day ago
  4.0
  I went to this unique pizza place with an almost factory-like aesthetic a while ago. Compared to some others, this isn't typical NYC pizza, being more Roman-style pizza al taglio, as it's cut more in a rectangle instead of a square. You can also find similar at My Pie Pizza Roma in Midtown East/my neighborhood, and like there, the crust is slightly thicker than a typical NYC slice and has a nice crunch to it. Along with pizza, they also sell custom pasta, sandwiches, and salads, with a notable number of vegan slices. The prices might seem a bit higher than the typical place, but they give a much larger portion. I was a bit unaware of this, so I got two, and this happened to be a very filling meal. The first was the Plain Cheese for $4.50, with aged mozzarella cheese and fresh tomato sauce. Due to the cheese selection, this was a bit less salty than other places, which I liked. For the sauce, it was bright and tasty, though I have preferred some other spots. It was good. My preference of the two was the more expensive slice, the $7 Emiliana, with aged mozzarella cheese, imported mortadella, pistachio cream, burrata cheese, and basil. This felt like more of a rich and indulgent slice due to the burrata and mortadella. Also, the unique nuttiness from the pistachio cream worked surprisingly well. While I usually don't like white slices, the various toppings more than made up for the lack of sauce, and this was easily one of my favorite white slices I have had. This is a tasty and unique slice shop. Would go back and try more.
• AK

  Anjana Karani

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Best sourdough crust.
• NF

  Nick Felker

  May 12, 2026
  4.0
  I only tried the rice ball when passing by during apartment hunting. The ball was okay, maybe still a bit too hot out of the oven. I expect I'll come back here once I move in.
• GG

  Giovanna G

  Apr 28, 2026
  5.0
  Davvero buona, personale gentile, con alcuni tavolini. Consigliata!
• AB

  Alicia Bullock

  Apr 25, 2026
  5.0
  The margarita. Pizza is great just the right amount of sauce and cheese and the crust is just the right crunch.tje mushroom pizza is great as well if you are in the mood for veggie the pepperoni and sausage is great to