Located near the High Line Trail and Hudson Yards, O'Toole's Way offers a dynamic dining experience that blends traditional Irish cuisine with modern culinary creativity. Our menu features inventive and flavorful dishes, rooted in classic techniques and inspired by Ireland’s rich culinary heritage. Whether you're savoring hearty, comforting favorites or exploring fresh, seasonal creations, every bite is crafted with care. Complement your meal with our thoughtfully curated cocktail menu, highlighting seasonal ingredients, or choose from our extensive selection of beer and wine, perfect for any occasion. Whether you're planning a corporate outing, a lively gathering with friends, or a cozy dinner, our warm and inviting space provides the ideal setting for an unforgettable dining experience.
Explore offerings from O'Toole's Way on 518 W 30th St, in New York, with popular small plates, irish bread service, soups and salads, and bar pies available at this location.
Very delicious and we seemed to have arrived at the perfect time for a Wednesday (~7:15pm). Got sat immediately and drinks came fairly quick. Wife had the espresso rubbed buffalo wings and she loved them. Crispy and sauced just right. I had the Lobster BLT and it was a fantastic twist to the classic.
EG
Elisa Geraldi
1 day ago
1.0
Double charged and still waiting for my refund
I had a very frustrating experience at this restaurant. I had already paid my bill, and the amount had already been charged to my card. I showed the server that the payment had gone through, but I was told that there was a problem with my card and that I needed to pay again.
I trusted the information I was given and paid the bill a second time. I was assured that the first charge would be refunded within one business day.
It has now been several days since the payment, and I still have not received the refund or even an update from the restaurant. I have already tried contacting them by email and Instagram DM, but I have received no response.
I understand that technical issues can happen, but what is unacceptable is being charged twice, being promised a refund within one business day, and then receiving no response or follow-up.
I am simply asking for the money that was incorrectly charged to my card to be refunded as promised.
SS
Saffron
Aug 14, 2026
5.0
Andrew was a fantastic server who allowed me to sample a few wines while giving discriptions of each of them. Andrew helped me discover a like for moscato!! I came with my dad and andrew really took good care of us :)
TR
Thomas R
Aug 13, 2026
5.0
Had a lovely evening at O’Toole’s with my cousin who was visiting. This was my first time here and our bartender Lavaniya was the nicest and guided my group through the menu with great suggestions and advice. 10/10 will return soon.
KA
Kamran Aslam
Jul 20, 2026
5.0
What an incredible spot to catch the World Cup! I came in yesterday with a group of 8 friends to watch the match, and honestly, the whole experience was perfect from start to finish.
Mark, the manager, made sure our group of 9 was taken care of the second we walked in — got us set up with a great view of the game and checked in throughout to make sure everything was running smoothly. That kind of attention to detail makes all the difference when you're hosting a big group.
Paula behind the bar was absolutely amazing. She kept the energy going all game long, was quick with drink orders even as the place got packed and rowdy during the big moments, and just had this warm, genuine way of making everyone feel like a regular. She never missed a beat with our group and somehow remembered everyone's order after the first round. Truly next-level hospitality — she's the kind of bartender that makes you want to come back just to see her again.
Lavaniya was fantastic too, working right alongside Paula to keep the food and drinks flowing for our whole crew without a single hiccup. Great teamwork behind that bar.
The food was excellent, the drinks were cold, and the atmosphere for the match was electric. O'Toole's Way has officially become our go-to spot for game days. Ask for Paula and Lavaniya if you want the best bartenders in the city — and tell Mark he's running a great bar. Can't wait to come back!
Yes, O'Toole's Way accepts reservations and you can book through their reservation page.
What are the kitchen hours at O'Toole's Way?
The kitchen is open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
When is brunch served at O'Toole's Way?
Brunch is served on Saturdays and Sundays from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM.
Does O'Toole's Way offer delivery service?
Yes, delivery is available and can be ordered online through their delivery URL.
What type of cuisine does O'Toole's Way specialize in?
O'Toole's Way offers a dynamic dining experience with traditional Irish cuisine blended with modern culinary creativity.
What is the dress code at O'Toole's Way?
The dress code is casual, making it a comfortable spot for any occasion.
What payment methods are accepted at O'Toole's Way?
They accept American Express, Apple Pay, MasterCard, and Visa.
Can you recommend nearby places to visit before or after dining at O'Toole's Way?
Guests can enjoy nearby attractions such as The High Line Trail and Hudson Yards, which are excellent for scenic walks and shopping experiences before or after your meal.
Are there convenient transit or ATM options near O'Toole's Way?
Yes, LibertyX Bitcoin ATM is nearby for quick currency exchange, and several convenience stores like Walgreens and Duane Reade are close for other essentials.
What nearby dining options are available around O'Toole's Way?
Nearby restaurants include Oyamel for Mexican cuisine, Leña for Spanish dishes, and Bar Celona, a tapas bar and restaurant, providing diverse dining alternatives.
Brand Certified Facts from O'Toole's Way
This information is certified by O'Toole's Way and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 16, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: