Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side

Reviews

• AL

  Arvin Lau

  1 day ago
  1.0
  Got a cheesecake here the other day and it gave me diarrhea within an hour of eating it. I gave them the benefit of the doubt and assumed it could be my body’s unusual reaction to dairy. I then had a dairy product the next day and my stomach was fine, confirming that that cheesecake was not edible. Please do better quality control of your products.
• KB

  KC Brown

  Jun 23, 2026
  5.0
  We got the banana pudding! It was fantastic BUT small and expensive. You can share the smaller/medium size can satisfy 2 people. Worth trying at least 1 time but due to price probably not more!
• JF

  Jenn Fauls

  Jun 18, 2026
  5.0
  Magnolia Bakery is amazing, but I have to say: everyone talks about the cupcakes, and they are great, but do not sleep on the banana pudding. It is insanely good. It is so good that I have made a special trip there right before a flight and flown across the country with it just so my dad could try it. It is truly next level. We always buy the largest size to bring home, and it never lasts long. I do not know what they put in it, but it is absolutely delicious: creamy, comforting, and completely addictive. I have tried other things here, and they have all been good, but the banana pudding is the thing I dream about. One word of warning: sometimes other restaurants or stores will offer Magnolia banana pudding, but in my experience, it is never quite as good as getting it fresh from the bakery. Skip the grocery store version and go straight to the source. It is absolutely worth it.
• HR

  Hidekel Reyes

  Jun 12, 2026
  1.0
  So they know they have faulty packaging, they recognize it and do not care. The workers are rude, unprofessional and just overall nasty. No sense of service or even pretend to care about what they are serving. Truly disgusting as I did use to enjoy the products.
• IB

  Iasmim Biasi

  Jun 2, 2026
  1.0
  Nada de mais. Por 11 dólares você come o famoso banana pudding… que é banana com creme rs mas o problema mesmo é o atendimento… horroroso! Mal educados, apressados,… e o local nada confortável para sentar e curtir um bom momento, cadeiras de metal, pouco espaço, música excessivamente alta… não achei nada de mais. Fujam que é hype furada!

Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side