Magnolia Bakery - Grand Central

Reviews

• AR

  Akif Çördük

  3 days ago
  2.0
  I had the banana pudding 4 years ago in the original store and was amazed by the taste. This time i could not finish the small portion as it tasted full of unhealthy sugar and didn't have good banana flavor. There was only one very small banana piece. Completely unsatisfied.
• GP

  Georgia Psarra

  5 days ago
  1.0
  Complete disappointment. Nothing special. There is really nothing here worth trying. I had a soggy biscuit with a mediocre mousse and some banana pieces. I don’t understand why there is so much hype around this. It’s a definite "no" from me.
• DE

  Dorothy Elizabeth

  May 1, 2026
  5.0
  Delicious!!! Love my sweet surprise! Blueberry Jamboree icebox bar, out of this world!!! 🥰 Caramel w/cookie perfect flavors together…and of course the BANANA PUDDING 🍌 I would 100% recommend Magnolia Bakery. From a sweet treat with coffee to bringing an array of small treats to your dinner party! A great point to be made, they have MULTIPLE locations…Looking forward to more sweets 🧁 🎂 ☕️
• JS

  Jardel dos Santos

  Apr 28, 2026
  5.0
  Assim, depois de comer um Shake Shack , fomos “tirar o gosto do salgado “ na Magnolia, que fica em frente. São muitas opções. Encaramos então um Lemon Bar, uma fatia de Bolo com amendoim e um Cupcake Red Welvet. Todos estavam muito bons. Precisamos voltar muitas vezes para provar os demais doces.
• CC

  Clara Campbell

  Apr 23, 2026
  1.0
  Zero organization, several workers standing around doing nothing, nobody being asked what they want to order, and one person periodically yelling to not line up out the door, an issue that would easily be fixed by someone engaging with customers. Tried to order at the counter and was told to wait until checkout. Got to checkout and was told I should have ordered by the counter. Teabag was broken so couldn’t even drink the tea. Cake was dry. No greetings, no thank you, no smiles from any staff. Zero stars.

Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery - Grand Central