Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South

Reviews

• II

  iRome2Grub’nPub

  2 days ago
  4.0
  It’s not worth waiting in line that’s out the door, but it’s so good, Karen.
• LO

  Laura Ximena Sánchez Ortiz

  2 days ago
  3.0
  El banana pudín es delicioso, pero solo la primera vez que lo pruebas; después se vuelve difícil de comer, porque es demasiado dulce. Las expectativas que tenía se cumplieron por un momento, pero luego tuve que botar medio bote de postre, porque tiene muchísima azúcar.
• KS

  Karishma Singh

  Apr 26, 2026
  2.0
  First time trying banana pudding from magnolia, it did not live up to its hype. It was bland,and liquid. The vanilla cupcake was better than the banana pudding
• AP

  AR Patel

  Apr 23, 2026
  1.0
  I love magnolia bakery banana pudding but this location for some reason has really runny whipped cream and does not justify how it usually tastes. I went back and let them know the consistency was off and they gave me another one but it seemed like that was from the same batch. Please avoid going to this location. Go to Venchi next door instead if you’re really looking for dessert
• PR

  P Rose

  Apr 7, 2026
  1.0
  The women working here on the morning of April 7 were just the worst I’ve ever experienced in all of the city. Horrible attitudes. So rude. I will never return. I just wanted a coffee. I asked if they had anything gluten free and they scowled at me and said no. Then I said that’s fine and asked for cream it seemed like I was really putting them out. Then they were rude to my friend after that and started arguing with her about the cream, even though she had asked for room for cream in hers. They said you have to ask for that ahead of time and I was like well. Is there a sign that tells you what you’re supposed to do here I’ve never been here before? Then they both started yelling at us and one of them told me to go to Starbucks and I was like gladly I will never return here. I should’ve gone to Starbucks in the first place apparently. It’s like they were just waiting to fight with some one. I just needed caffeine. The coffee wasn’t even good. So disappointing - especially in an area of the city that should be well represented by people that are friendly and accommodating.

Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South