Magnolia Bakery

Reviews

• RC

  Remmas Chahreddine

  1 day ago
  4.0
  The Magnolia Bakery banana pudding is seriously one of the best I’ve ever had in my entire life. I had heard about it long before I even traveled to New York City, and visiting Magnolia was one of the things I had planned to do. I finally made it there tonight, literally about 10 minutes before closing. They were kind enough to let me get the banana pudding, but when I asked if I could also get a coffee to take away, they said they were about to close. Totally understandable. What made me laugh, though, was when I went to the cashier to pay for my one banana pudding, she asked, “Anything else?” 😂 I was thinking, “Well… I tried to get a coffee, but you guys said you were about to close!” Anyway, no complaints because that banana pudding was absolutely worth the visit. 10/10. One of the best banana puddings I’ve ever had. Definitely lived up to the hype.
• CM

  Christina Mayfield

  Aug 10, 2026
  1.0
  I'm not sure what happened but my husband and I travel atleast once a month so he can get his cake slices and this time around they was so bad we got back to RI and went to have a slice and it was very dry and didn't taste like it usually does. He spent $27 n some change and I spent about the same for a slice and pudding and cheesecake slice. Both of our cake slices was so bad.all 4 of his was terrible. We got the same slices too. Just bad. We spent alot of money to get home and not be able to enjoy it. I usually wouldn't do this but when I called I was told nothing can be done because how far away I am. Doesn't matter we travel to NYC atleast once a month we going back in either September or October. My husband loves Magnolia cake slices the one in the video is his favorite for sure. But Idk if he is gonna spend that much next time around. Usually he can trust it and not worry if it will be bad. Idk what happened but it was bad. Also the cashier didn't seam happy. Usually the workers are wonderful happy out going. Nothing this time around.
• ML

  Melissa Lotus

  Aug 6, 2026
  4.0
  Whenever I'm back in NYC and taking Amtrak, I always make a stop here for the banana pudding. Honestly, it's the only thing I've tried, so I can't speak on anything else on the menu. I've seen reviews saying it's not "real" banana pudding, but I actually prefer this style. It's thicker, almost like a whipped cake and I like it even more than traditional pudding. I also like that it has a nice banana flavor without being overloaded with banana pieces. Everyone's taste buds are different, so I understand why the texture might not be for everyone. But I truly enjoyed it. In my opinion, it's some of the best banana pudding I've had that wasn't homemade. I'll definitely be back for more.
• BR

  Bonnie Roush

  Aug 4, 2026
  5.0
  I was never a fan of banana pudding until I had this!! We ate breakfast here Saturday morning and it was Delicious! We stopped back on Sunday to buy more to take home! They also have a wonderful selection of so many more good treats. I love the Red Velvet Cheesecake too!
• KS

  Kübra S.

  Jul 28, 2026
  4.0
  Magnolia Bakery'nin Banana Puding'i New York'ta yenilebilecek en güzel ve hafif tatlıların başında geliyor. 1 büyük boy 2 kişiye fazlasıyla yetiyor. Fiyatı makul, büyük boy 8 usd civarıydı. Çok beğendik. Görevliler çok tatlı. Tren garındaki şubede oturacak yer yok maalesef. Sadece paket servis var.

Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery