Jonny's Pizza

Reviews

• DD

  Drew Dorshorst

  6 days ago
  5.0
  I had the vodka pep Jonny's way and it was probably the best slice of pizza I've ever had in my life!
• AA

  Amar

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  This is a hidden pizza gem in NYC I get that people like the popular spot like Industrie and Joes but this place is stellar and a classic for me now.
• AM

  alfred munoz

  May 6, 2026
  1.0
  I'm just mad I didn't take a picture before I took one bite and threw this worst slice I've ever had in New York City worse than the dollar slices you can get in Times Square that bad! It literally was tomato sauce out of the can with half cheese ratio it was like eating a bite of tomato soup, I don't know about the Vodka slice or the other slices but it's obvious you have to put hot honey burrata and chili oil on the cheese slice to give it flavor
• SS

  Sam

  Apr 28, 2026
  5.0
  Great slice - Margarita is all you need! Perfect base, doughy but crispy and a good ratio of Cheese/tomato Finished with Oregano and chefs kiss
• AE

  Adrian Essayan

  Apr 22, 2026
  1.0
  We ordered a large vodka pizza to go. When they boxed it up, it looked exactly like a plain cheese pizza. Since we had already been there the day before, we had seen both pizzas and tasted both, so we knew perfectly well what the vodka pizza was supposed to look and taste like. I asked if they were sure. I opened the box, looked them straight in the eye, and asked again. They reassured us and guaranteed that it was the vodka pizza. We got home, started eating, and it was plainly just a cheese pizza. What is most frustrating is not just the mistake itself, but the fact that we raised the issue twice, were reassured twice, and were still handed the wrong pizza with complete confidence, as if we would not notice. At that point, it honestly makes you wonder whether they thought we would not notice, or whether tourists are simply expected to accept whatever gets put in the box. And to make matters worse, we paid for the more expensive pizza and received the cheaper one. Very disappointing, especially since we had come back for a second day in a row. Adrian

Frequently Asked Questions About Jonny's Pizza