George Keeley

Reviews

• MG

  Michael Gill

  Mar 22, 2026
  1.0
  We've tried this place twice now, both times we had to walk out after being unable to get service. First time it was busy, but regardless, more than 10 mins without even an acknowledgement from wait staff. Walked out. Today we sat at an almost empty bar in clear view of the bartender. He hung out at the end of the bar with staff doing what appeared to be comparing March madness picks (they were on their phones, whatever they were doing). Another staff member sat at the bar eating, looked at us several times but after 7-8 mins we got up and left. They saw us walk out without a comment or a care. Won't go back. Too many other great options in the neighborhood.
• SO

  Sarah O

  Feb 18, 2026
  5.0
  Our favorite bar on the UWS! Great selection of beer, underrated food, and the best bartenders.
• DC

  David Cee

  Feb 16, 2026
  5.0
  Good food and an honest drink.
• JS

  Joel Benjamin Smith

  Feb 6, 2026
  3.0
  I’m interested to know the bar’s view on what’s an acceptable tip when ordering drinks at the bar (i.e. no table service), as we were accosted on exit for ‘only’ leaving $13 for 13 drinks on the check (and 20% for the one item of food delivered to the table). Sour end to the visit. It’s a shame, as otherwise it’s a great bar.
• MM

  Madison M.

  Jan 11, 2026
  1.0
  I got to the bar before my friend and ordered a soda. I can’t have alcohol right now for personal reasons anyway, but my friend drinks. My friend ran 20 minutes late. While I waited, I drank the soda and browsed my phone, (there were open seats as well, I wasn’t keeping people from getting served) then a couple other patrons sitting right beside me started making fun of me to the bartender for ordering a soda and using my phone. They said, “don’t you hate it when people do that? Just go to a library, why are you here? The worst! Etc etc”He agreed and joked with them. I know for sure they were talking about me because I ended up glaring and one of the guys said sorry. I was minding my own business. I’d have left except for my friend. It was a shocking experience. Very unprofessional and antagonistic of the bartender as well. Weird and off putting, will not return and will recommend my friends to avoid in future.

Frequently Asked Questions About George Keeley