Brand Certified
Church of Heavenly Rest Café
4.3(1897 reviews)
Certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café • May 17, 2026
Business Details
1085 5th Ave, New York, NY
10128, United States
Certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café • May 17, 2026
(718) 374-6858
Certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café • May 17, 2026
https://bluestonelane.com/cafes/upper-east-side-1085-fifth-avenue-new-york/
Certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café • May 17, 2026
About
Certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café • May 17, 2026
Coffee ShopBarCafeBluestone Lane
Nestled within the historic Church of the Heavenly Rest along Museum Mile, directly opposite Central Park, the Church's Upper East Side Café is one of our most special locations — operated by Bluestone Lane and beloved by the local community.
In partnership with the Church, we proudly operate the café on behalf of the church as part of this extraordinary community space — welcoming locals, visitors, and parishioners alike throughout the day. On weekends, we also serve coffee alongside Church services, extending the ritual of gathering from café to congregation.
Framed by the Church's original sandstone architecture and vaulted archways, the space offers a calm, light-filled setting that feels both elevated and deeply grounded in its surroundings.
It's a place to pause — whether for a morning coffee, a long brunch, or a quiet moment between walks along Fifth Avenue.
Our menu reflects Bluestone Lane's signature approach to modern café culture — seasonal, produce-driven dishes designed to complement our specialty coffee program.
From Avocado Smash and house-made granola to our much-loved Gluten-Free Banana Bread, the offering is familiar, nourishing, and consistently high quality.
Beyond daytime service, we also collaborate with the Church to host evening and special events — bringing people together through shared experiences, conversation, and community.
With indoor table service and outdoor seating along Fifth Avenue, this is a destination to discover — where café culture meets one of New York's most iconic and historic settings.
To host your next event with us, visit our Private Events page.
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- DebitAvailable
Location
Certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café • May 17, 2026
Hours
Certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café • May 17, 2026
Monday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sunday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Reviews
4.3
1,897 reviews
5 stars
1,318
4 stars
264
3 stars
92
2 stars
75
1 star
148
- GBgabi barry6 days ago5.0I genuinely cannot say enough good things about Bluestone Lane. This has become my absolute favorite spot in the city — not just because the food is incredible, but because every single experience here feels so warm and welcoming. The service is always above and beyond. Every staff member is consistently kind, attentive, and makes you feel truly cared for, which is honestly rare to find in NYC. We were served by Abel during our last visit, and he was SO incredibly kind and thoughtful. He really took care of us from start to finish and even surprised us with a sweet treat, which completely made our day. It’s those little gestures that make this place feel special and memorable every single time. The food is phenomenal with so many healthy options, amazing brunch choices, and everything always tastes fresh and beautifully made. Whether you’re stopping in for coffee, brunch, or just somewhere peaceful to relax, it never disappoints. One of my favorite things about this location is the atmosphere. On a beautiful day, sitting outside is perfect for people watching along Fifth Avenue. But inside is just as stunning the café is nestled into an old church, which gives it such a unique, cozy, and almost magical feeling. It somehow feels both peaceful and lively at the same time. This place truly has my heart. Amazing food, beautiful atmosphere, and the sweetest people working there. I’ll keep coming back again and again. 🤍
- KRKirk Che Reddulus6 days ago2.0Food is tasty, but service was very bad even it was not overcrowded. I didn't received my order and customers who came after me finished their orders and finally left. And still i didn't get my order.
- TATati AnaMay 13, 20265.0I come here frequently , and love the service provided by all the staff. Especially Abel, who is consistently attentive and warm. A great place for a coffee run or mid day break. Big fan of the matcha berry drink and pastries.
- SFSavanna FuscoMay 9, 20265.0This was my first time here and it was amazing. The staff were so friendly especially our waiter Abel he was so personable and willing to answer all our questions and gave great recommendations. We ended up having the banana bread which was to die for, and I got a brown sugar vanilla latte his personal fav, sooo delicious!!!
- JCJohn CacciapuotiMay 9, 20265.0It was my girlfriend and I first time here and we were celebrating her birthday. Our waiter Abel provided amazing customer service and gave us great options to have a great first time here with the banana bread and the vanilla latte with brown sugar! Amazing food, coffee and service
Frequently Asked Questions About Church of Heavenly Rest Café
What type of cuisine and experience does Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café offer?
Bluestone Lane offers an Australian-inspired coffee shop and café experience with premium coffee and healthy, delicious eats, embracing an 'Aussie' approach to life.
Where is Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café located?
It is located at 1085 5th Ave, New York, NY 10128, USA.
What are the operating hours of Bluestone Lane on weekdays and weekends?
Bluestone Lane is open Monday to Friday from 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and on Saturdays and Sundays from 7:30 AM to 6:00 PM.
Which payment methods are accepted at Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café?
Bluestone Lane accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Does Bluestone Lane offer options for dining in, takeout, or catering?
Yes, Bluestone Lane provides dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering services.
What kind of food and drinks can I find on the Bluestone Lane menu?
The menu includes coffee, tea, juices, avocado smash, granola, and café fare with specialties like wellness lattes, breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dessert options.
Is Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café accessible for people with disabilities?
Yes, the café has wheelchair accessible entrances and seating.
What nearby places can I visit along with Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café?
Nearby places include the Church of the Heavenly Rest, Engineers' Gate park, and the National Academy School of Fine Arts, offering opportunities for sightseeing and cultural visits before or after your café experience.
Are there other coffee shops or cafés near Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café?
Yes, Tarallucci e Vino is a nearby Italian restaurant and café, providing additional dining options in the area.
How can I get to Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café using local transit or nearby landmarks?
You can find Bluestone Lane near notable landmarks like the Mayor John Purroy Mitchel Memorial and the Eastside Comprehensive Medical Center, which can help orient your way to the café on 5th Avenue.
Brand Certified Facts from Church of Heavenly Rest Café
This information is certified by Church of Heavenly Rest Café and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified May 17, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: