Blue Fin

Reviews

• RF

  Ruby Freed

  1 day ago
  5.0
  We had dinner between shows after reading about the restaurant online. We both had the red snapper special- delicious! Our server Tye was THE BEST! Food, drinks, service- I highly recommend it.
• DT

  Debra Thomas

  1 day ago
  5.0
  We enjoyed a lovely evening at Blue Fin 7/25/26. Our waiter, John Hall, was delightful, attentive and so very helpful. The food was delicious: lobster bisque with chunks of sweet, tender lobster in a warm soothing broth, salmon cooked to perfection and the potato wedges were perfectly seasoned. Good portions. Wanted dessert, but too full to order more! I’ll plan to visit again next time in Times Square. Thank you John!
• JD

  Jordan Dyson

  2 days ago
  5.0
  The restaurant’s atmosphere was lovely, a bit of calm in the chaos of Times Square. Though the menu was a bit limited, our server John Hall was absolutely incredible - he was so full of joy and brought a smile to all of our faces. My 9 year old daughter was skeptical that she’d find something she would enjoy, but John made sure her salmon was cooked perfectly and even made sure her fries and side veggie would be exactly to her liking. This is the one meal she praised high on our trip to NYC, and I know that wouldn’t have happened without John’s kindness and careful attention to her needs. Thank you John!
• BS

  Brittany Simon

  Jul 8, 2026
  5.0
  Great sushi and wine. Perfect for pre or post theatre
• YY

  Yumoyori

  Jun 15, 2026
  1.0
  Traveled from Toronto, Canada to experience this restaurant and what a disappointment ambience was good, the aesthetic was amazing, but we made reservations, only standing there not to be acknowledge for a few minutes. Then the woman who looks like a manager apologized for the wait and brought us to our table. Our server was nice in the beginning, but after that it felt like it was going down hill. It was interesting how our serve (black gentlemen) treated us kinda with minimum regard while the white server who service the individuals next to us was on point with his serving (this isn’t necessarily a racial problem because both guest at both tables were of color, but it was a very interesting acknowledgement that I hated to experience or acknowledge). We waited and got shrimp cocktails and oysters, then as we waited for our mains (after the guy asked if we needed anything else which I mean we ordered appetizers? Like why would you ask if we need anything else as if we’re done?) food took 20 mins to which the man brought us bread and said he’d get us some butter. Why did the main food come out and we waited an additional 10 minutes for butter. By then the bread was cold… I requested for the bread to be rewarmed and again this is where the server attitude shifted like we were some nuisance when you had us waiting 20 minutes for a main dish and another 10 for bread? (And this goes back to the white server who was on point who brought the bread at the beginning of the wait time before the appetizers and main course was delivered). When our server brought the bill he literally placed it there and walked away. No thank you for joining us, nothing. Versus the white server next to us who legit thanked the couple for eating with them and said if they needed anything to call for him. It left such a sour taste to be treated like basic trash for $150 dollar USD meal (which is $250 CAD DOLLARS) and then you’re expecting 15-20% gratuity for slow service and attitude? I don’t know if he assumed we didn’t look the aesthetic or what it is but to judge someone when we dressed up and wanted a nice dinner this was unacceptable. Thank goodness I didn’t book this place for my actual friend’s birthday cause it would have been a pure disappointment. Location was easy to access but again, when leaving we couldn’t go thru the street entrance and was stuck. The cook waved to us to go out the back way to get out. Overall, DO NOT recommend. This place is simply good for your average dine in, but “fine” dining, go somewhere else where they value your money and treat you properly instead of assuming your some commoner (coming from a 7 figure USA Today bestselling author who price bracket just fine).

Frequently Asked Questions About Blue Fin